The clasp on my purse caught a thread of my navy dress. I worked it loose instead of looking at the casket. After four hours in the car from Muncie, I needed something small I could fix.
Wayne, my husband, was parking. My eighteen-year-old sister, Kayla, had hugged me outside. Her mother, Patricia, had inspected my dress.
Patricia married Dad nineteen years ago, when I was thirteen. Kayla came a year later. Dad had adopted me at three; when my mother left when I was six, he stayed my father without requiring applause.
I took a seat on the left, up front. During my two minutes with him, I found his hair parted on the left instead of the right. I stood to correct it.
Patricia steered me past the bowling league and neighbors to the coat rack.
“The front is for blood, sweetheart. You were his project.”
Dad’s cousin Lyle looked down. Mrs. Haskins stared. Wayne found me there, and I stopped him from confronting Patricia. Lou, Dad’s foreman, offered me another seat. I refused that, too.
Kayla texted that Patricia would take her car if she moved.
Since Dad got sick in March, I’d driven down every other weekend, learned his port care, stayed through nights. In July, Patricia and her sister, Sharon, went to Myrtle Beach. Three days before the funeral, at four in the morning, hospice called me.
Now the pastor announced Sharon would give the remarks. My speech, requested by Dad in April, stayed folded in my purse.
Then Mr. Pruitt approached with a black folder. Three days earlier, I’d brought him Dad’s brown suit and good watch; he’d checked the spelling of my name twice.
Dad had visited him secretly in May, prepaid the service, and named me to direct it.
Patricia came down the aisle to object.
Mr. Pruitt handed me the folder. Past the service plan and my circled name, he turned to a page Dad had titled: ABOUT PATRICIA’S SEAT.
The Third Page
I held the bottom corner against my knee. Dad had pressed hard enough with his pen to leave a hole beside the heading.
Patricia took another step.
“That is private,” she said. “Whatever he wrote, that belongs to his wife.”
I lowered my eyes to the first line.
“Patricia belongs in the front row with my daughters.”
For a second I couldn’t read any farther.
There it was. Her place protected in his handwriting, while I sat beside somebody’s raincoat. Even now, he was making sure she had a cushion under her.
Patricia reached toward the folder.
“Exactly. Now give me that, and we can start.”
I pulled it against my chest. She stopped reaching.
“There’s more,” I said.
Wayne stood beside me without touching the page. He waited while I found the next line.
“My daughters sit together. Their husbands can sit with them. Patricia may sit beside them if she can leave them in peace. If she cannot, offer her another row. Do not move either girl to accommodate her.”
Below that, his writing grew smaller.
“She has called my oldest a guest before. I let it pass to get through supper. I should have got up. Please do better than I did.”
My thumb covered the hole in the paper.
Dad knew.
That hurt in a place I wasn’t ready to have hurt. I wanted to be grateful. I also wanted him alive long enough to ask why a funeral director had to say what he could have said across his own living room.
Mr. Pruitt stayed quiet.
At the bottom Dad had written one more instruction.
“My oldest gives the remarks she promised me. No substitutions. If there is trouble, ask her what she wants. Don’t make her look after everybody else.”
I read that twice.
Patricia’s hand was still out, palm up, as if I were holding her change at a register.
“He was taking medication in May,” she said. “You know that. He got confused about things. There were days he didn’t remember whether he’d eaten.”
“He discussed these arrangements with me himself,” Mr. Pruitt said.
“Well, you didn’t live with him.”
“No, ma’am.”
“You saw him for an hour. I was his wife for nineteen years.”
I closed the folder far enough to keep her from reading over my hand.
“Nineteen,” I said. “I remember all of them.”
She looked toward the front. Sharon was on her feet now, her husband beside her, Patricia’s two cousins still seated. Kayla had turned around again. This time she didn’t turn back.
Patricia leaned closer to me.
“Are you really going to do this here? People came to mourn your father.”
I wanted to tell her I had come for the same reason, before she’d given me a tour of the coat storage. The words crowded my mouth. None would come out without shaking.
Mr. Pruitt bent slightly toward me.
“Would you like a moment in the side room?”
A side room. Another door between Dad and me.
“No.”
My answer surprised Wayne. His hand moved toward my shoulder, then stopped.
I opened the folder again.
“Did he ask you to read this aloud?”
“No,” Mr. Pruitt said. “He asked me to make sure you read it. The decisions are yours.”
That mattered. Dad hadn’t left me a script for punishing his wife. He’d left instructions she couldn’t quietly replace.
Across the room, the pastor stepped away from the podium.
“I owe you an apology,” he said to me. “I was told you had decided you couldn’t speak.”
Patricia turned.
“She was upset. Look at her. I was trying to spare her.”
The pastor kept his eyes on me.
“Did you withdraw?”
“No.”
My purse had slipped onto the chair. I opened it and took out the page I’d written on both sides. The fold was nearly white from all the times I’d opened it in the car.
Wayne had driven while I practiced. I’d made it as far as the second paragraph before telling him to turn on the radio.
Now I held the speech in one hand and Dad’s instructions in the other. A ridiculous amount of paper for a woman trying to say goodbye.
“I still want to speak,” I said.
“Of course,” the pastor said.
Patricia put her tissue to her mouth for the first time.
“Sharon prepared something. You can’t simply embarrass her.”
Sharon came halfway down the aisle.
“You told me she didn’t write anything,” she said.
“Sharon, please.”
“You said nobody else would do it.”
Patricia looked from her sister to me. She was losing the arrangement she had made, one person at a time, and she wanted me to be ashamed enough to put it back.
Mr. Pruitt waited.
I put my speech back in my purse, keeping the folder.
“Kayla,” I said. “Would you come here?”
My sister stood before her mother could answer.
The Walk Up the Aisle
Kayla squeezed past Sharon’s husband and came toward me with her phone clenched in her hand.
Patricia stepped into her path.
“Sit down. We have kept everyone waiting long enough.”
Kayla stopped so abruptly that her shoe squeaked. That small sound nearly broke me. She was eighteen, dressed for her father’s funeral, and still waiting for permission to cross a room.
I moved into the aisle.
“She can come to me.”
“Don’t interfere with my daughter.”
“Our father died,” Kayla said.
Patricia’s mouth opened, then closed.
Kayla went around her and reached me. I put the folder on my chair and held her with both arms. She pushed her face against my shoulder.
“I’m sorry,” she said.
“You hugged me outside. I needed that.”
“I should have got up.”
“You’re up now.”
Wayne took my purse so I could keep holding her. He had been ready to go to war over a folding chair ten minutes earlier. Now he stood with a woman’s handbag hooked over his wrist and tears on his face.
Patricia came closer.
“This has become completely inappropriate. Kayla, I told you what would happen if you started carrying on.”
Kayla lifted her head.
“I wasn’t carrying on. I wanted to sit with my sister.”
“We will discuss this at home.”
She looked at the phone in Kayla’s hand. My sister tucked it against her side.
I could have read Dad’s whole page to the room. I wanted to. The mean part of me wanted Patricia to hear every word bounce off those walls.
Instead, I picked up the folder and opened it to the paragraph about the seats.
“Dad asked for his daughters to sit together,” I said. “Wayne is sitting with me. You can sit beside us.”
Patricia stared at me.
“Can?”
“Yes.”
“I don’t require your permission to sit at my own husband’s funeral.”
“Then don’t ask me to sit behind his neighbors.”
Mrs. Haskins rose from her chair.
“She took her by the arm,” she said. “I was right there.”
Patricia turned toward her.
“I was helping her find a place.”
“No,” Mrs. Haskins said.
One word. Clear enough to reach the podium.
Lyle finally lifted his head.
“I saw it too,” he said.
Patricia’s cheeks reddened. She looked toward Sharon, who stood with her hands clasped over the remarks she’d brought.
“Would somebody remember that I have lost my husband?”
“I do,” I said. “You can sit with us.”
“But you want to dictate everything. You arrive from Muncie and suddenly you’re in charge. I was there every day. I took care of the house. I dealt with the deliveries, the prescriptions, everything nobody sees.”
I let her finish.
There were things she had done. Dad’s illness had been long. She could have listed them until evening, and none would have explained putting me beside the coats.
“You don’t know what it was like,” she said.
“I know what you called me.”
Her eyes flicked toward the casket.
“Oh, for heaven’s sake. You always take things the worst possible way.”
“Tell them what you meant by project.”
She pulled her tissue between her fingers.
“I meant he took you on. He was a generous man. Everybody knows that. Your mother left him with a child, and he stepped up.”
Kayla pulled away from me.
“He adopted her before that.”
“I know when he adopted her.”
“Then stop saying it like he got stuck with her.”
“Kayla.”
“No.”
My sister was crying openly now. She didn’t wipe her face. Patricia reached for her elbow, and Kayla moved behind my shoulder.
Sharon folded her own paper in half.
“Patricia, move out of the aisle.”
“You’re taking her side?”
“You told me she wanted to be in the back. You told me she wasn’t speaking.”
“I was trying to get through this morning.”
“So was she,” Sharon said.
She returned to the front row and picked up her purse. Her husband stood with her. They moved to the row behind, and the two cousins followed.
Nobody clapped. Thank God. My father was lying ten feet away, and this wasn’t a game show with a consolation prize.
But four places opened where Patricia had arranged her people around her.
I held out my hand to Kayla.
Patricia’s face changed when my sister took it.
“Remember the car,” she said.
Wayne shifted beside me.
“We’ll get you home today,” he said to Kayla.
That was all he promised. A ride. Something he could actually give, without pretending we could settle the rest of her life before the service.
Kayla nodded.
Patricia looked at me again.
“Are you going to let her speak to me like that?”
“We’re going to sit down.”
I took one step, then stopped beside her.
“The seat beside us is yours if you leave us alone.”
She stood in the aisle while Kayla and I walked past. Wayne followed with my purse. At the front, I set the folder on the chair and turned back.
Patricia hadn’t moved.
“After nineteen years, this is what I get?” she said.
I was tired of nineteen years being used as a receipt she could present for ownership.
“You get a seat,” I said. “Not mine.”
His Right Side
Patricia looked toward Sharon again.
Her sister lowered herself into the second row without making room beside her husband. There was space farther along, but nobody reached for Patricia or asked me to reconsider.
She came up the aisle slowly. At the front row, she stopped by the empty chair beside Kayla.
My sister tightened her grip on my hand.
Patricia saw it. She took the chair at the far end instead, leaving a space between herself and Kayla. She sat with her purse on her knees.
For once, she had to sit where my father had put her without moving somebody else.
Mr. Pruitt approached me.
“Are you ready?”
“One thing first.”
I went to the casket.
The part was still on the wrong side. All that arguing, and there it was, the first thing I’d wanted to do that morning.
“Do you have a comb?” I said.
Mr. Pruitt brought one. I bent over Dad and moved his hair back toward the right.
My hand shook. I steadied my wrist against the edge of the casket, embarrassed by how careful I had to be. I’d flushed a port and held a basin and figured out medication alarms. A comb had me beaten.
Kayla came to stand beside me.
“A little more there,” she said.
“Bossy.”
“He wouldn’t want that bit sticking up.”
I smoothed it with my fingers.
Dad looked more like himself. Not alive. I wasn’t foolish enough to expect that. Just himself, in the brown suit I’d brought, with his good watch at his cuff.
I handed back the comb.
The pastor began after we sat down. He corrected the announcement before he read anything else.
“His daughter will give the remarks, as her father requested.”
Patricia stared at the flowers.
When my turn came, Wayne passed me the paper from my purse. There was a dent where I’d gripped it in the back row. I rubbed it flat against my leg.
At the podium, the first sentence blurred.
I waited.
Dad’s bowling friends sat with their hands folded. Lou leaned forward. Lyle met my eyes this time, and Mrs. Haskins had a tissue pressed beneath her nose.
I looked down at my page again.
“My dad asked me to keep this short,” I said. “Which was bold coming from a man who could spend twenty minutes explaining uneven tire wear.”
Lou laughed. It broke halfway through.
My next breath went all the way in.
“He sold tires. If you asked him what he did, that was usually his answer. He never mentioned the people he gave rides to while their cars were being worked on, or the ones he let pay him Friday.”
I read the words I’d brought. I didn’t add the coat rack. Patricia didn’t get a paragraph in my goodbye.
I told them about a father who came when I called, and who could make a child feel that getting picked up from school was the most ordinary thing in the world.
At the line about my mother leaving, I stopped.
Kayla leaned forward in her chair.
I found her face and continued.
“I don’t remember the adoption papers. I was three. I remember being six and asking if I needed to pack.”
My paper shook against the podium.
“He opened my dresser drawer and put my socks away. That’s the part I remember. He put the socks away.”
Nobody moved.
I let myself cry then. It made the next sentence messy. Dad had heard me with a stuffy nose plenty of times; I didn’t suppose he needed a polished version now.
“When Kayla was born, he put her in my arms and stayed right there because I was afraid I’d drop her. She was very small. I was very sure babies could tell when you didn’t know what you were doing.”
Kayla covered her mouth.
“I got to be her sister because I was his daughter.”
I folded the paper when I finished. Both sides read. Nothing taken out to make room for Sharon.
Wayne stood when I reached our row. I sat between him and Kayla, and for the rest of the service my sister held my hand in her lap.
When the pastor finished, Mr. Pruitt gave us a few minutes at the casket before the lid would be closed.
Patricia went first. I stayed seated. Her goodbye belonged to her, and I had no wish to reach into it.
Then she picked up her purse.
“Kayla, come along.”
Kayla stood beside me.
“I’m staying until she’s finished.”
Patricia waited. My sister didn’t move.
Sharon came forward and walked out with Patricia. No one asked me to hurry.
I set my speech in the folder and gave it to Wayne. Then Kayla and I went to Dad together.
She straightened his cuff over the watch. I touched the place in his hair I’d fixed.
“He looks right now,” she said.
I nodded, but my face crumpled before I could answer. Kayla put her arm around my waist, and I leaned on my little sister.
We stayed until we were ready.
At the door, Wayne held out my purse. I took it without catching the dress this time.
Kayla slipped her hand into mine and walked with me past the coat rack.
Stories about family secrets and being treated as an outsider continue in the mother who mailed away her baby picture and the store manager who made a little boy hide. For a gentler story about love finding its way through the hard days, read the daughter who kept nineteen letters by the laundry.




