My Brother Kept Me in My Lawn Chair for His Joke

The lid on Nana’s old Pyrex never fit right. I wrestled it off at one that Saturday afternoon and set the dish on her table, orange chip facing away from the children.

Two hours from Joplin to Broken Arrow, and I was worrying about a dish. Easier than worrying about Darren.

Nana June was turning eighty-one. Her Tuesday-night invitation a week before had interrupted her television show, which meant attendance wasn’t optional. I’d planned four hours, homeward by five.

My brother found me at ten after one.

Darren, forty-six to my forty-three, sold used pontoon boats outside Tulsa. That afternoon he sold the family the idea that my twenty years in the Army were a joke. Questions about my pension, my job, whether I carried a gun. I answered no, yes, no.

Mom laughed. Uncle Desmond joined in. I thought about being nine, locked in Darren’s tool shed, counting to five thousand beside the mower while he claimed I’d gone to the creek.

At four thirty, Hollis Pruitt arrived in a gray pickup. Grandpa Roy’s hunting partner wore polished boots despite the heat. He paused during our handshake, studying my face, then moved along.

Nana persuaded me to stay for cake.

By dusk, Darren had his fourth beer and about eight relatives gathered near the cooler. All thirty-one of us could hear him demanding details of my service.

He stood over my lawn chair and tossed a pretend punch toward my face. I admitted to close-combat training. He offered Cupcake as a possible nickname.

I held my lemonade.

“Gravedigger.”

Fifteen feet away, Hollis dropped his mason jar beside the smoker. Tea spread between the flagstones. His face drained. Darren turned toward him; Nana lowered her fork.

Hollis stepped through the glass, his hand still raised.

“Lord have mercy,” he said. “You’re Gravedigger.”

The Man Beside the Smoker

I set my lemonade down on the ground before I stood. My knee caught the chair and dragged it a few inches behind me.

“Don’t move your feet,” I said. “There’s glass.”

Hollis looked down as if someone had only just installed the patio beneath him.

“Yes,” he said. “There is.”

Uncle Desmond went for a broom. Nobody told him to. He’d spent the afternoon finding Darren funny, but apparently broken glass was a problem he understood.

Hollis took a careful step clear.

“Afghanistan,” he said. “Two thousand ten.”

My hand stayed on the chair.

“A compound wall came down. Three men underneath.”

I hadn’t heard that description spoken in a backyard before. There were mosquitoes around my ankles and somebody’s paper plate folding under barbecue sauce. I wanted those things to keep being the whole afternoon.

Hollis swallowed.

“My son was one of them.”

I looked at him properly then. The shape of his mouth. His eyes.

“Pruitt,” I said.

He nodded hard.

“He was by the doorway?”

“Yes.”

“The one who kept asking about the other two?”

Hollis pressed his lips together and nodded again.

I sat back down.

Darren’s hands finally dropped to his sides.

Hollis came closer, stopping where he could see my face without standing over me.

“My boy said somebody kept digging after they told her to get back. Said there was still fire coming into the courtyard. She made a hole big enough to reach him.”

“There were other people helping.”

“He told me that too.”

“Good.”

“He also told me you stayed with him until they could pull him clear.”

I rubbed my thumb over a seam in my trousers. Dirt had worked into the seams of my gloves that day. I remembered that better than the noise.

Hollis turned enough to include the family.

“She helped dig my son and two other men out of a collapsed compound. All three came home.”

Aunt Jeanette put her hand over her mouth again. This time she wasn’t hiding a laugh.

“That’s why you know the name?” Mom said.

“That’s why.”

He looked back at me.

“Sixteen years I’ve tried to find you.”

I shook my head.

“You didn’t have to do that.”

“I wanted to thank you.”

He took a breath that caught halfway through.

“My son had a head injury. The first things he could tell us were pieces. A voice. Dirt in his mouth. Somebody on the radio calling for Gravedigger. Later he remembered your face, but he never got your name.”

“People got moved around.”

“I asked him. Asked people he served with. Wrote down every lead somebody gave me. After a while I stopped asking so often.”

His shoulders lifted.

“I didn’t stop hoping.”

Desmond swept the glass into a dustpan. The scrape sounded enormous.

Hollis pointed toward me, then lowered his hand as if he worried pointing might be rude.

“He said you told him he could complain when he was outside.”

I let out a breath that almost became a laugh.

“He was complaining about my elbow.”

“That’s what he said.”

“I had it in his ribs.”

“He said that too.”

There he was. A young man beneath broken masonry, irritated with the woman trying to reach his shoulder. Alive enough to be annoyed.

“How is he?” I said.

Hollis pulled a phone out of his shirt pocket, fumbled it, and caught it against his stomach.

I held out my hand.

“Take your time.”

He found a photograph and handed it over. His son stood beside a garage with a little girl on his shoulders. She’d planted both palms across his forehead like she was steering a lawn mower.

I touched the edge of the screen.

“He looks good.”

“He is good. Some days his headaches aren’t. But he’s here.”

I handed the phone back before the faces blurred.

Hollis crouched, then changed his mind halfway down. At sixty-eight, his knees apparently had their own chain of command. I pulled the empty chair beside mine toward him.

“Sit before Nana has two of us to fuss over.”

He sat.

“Can I shake your hand?”

I gave it to him. He covered it with both of his and bent his head.

“Thank you,” he said.

There wasn’t a clever thing in me. Not one.

“You’re welcome.”

Darren cleared his throat.

“Well, hell. Tara, you could’ve told us.”

I pulled my hand free slowly.

He spread his arms toward the yard.

“How were we supposed to know? You come home, you don’t say anything. You let everybody think you worked in an office.”

Hollis started to stand.

I touched his sleeve.

“No. Stay.”

I’d let people speak for me all afternoon. Darren supplied the jokes. Mom supplied the permission. Now Hollis was prepared to supply a defense.

I could manage one sentence myself.

“Darren, come back here.”

He’d begun edging toward the picnic table and his tipped beer.

“Why?”

“Because we’re going to finish this.”

The Empty Space Around Darren

Darren stayed beside the picnic table.

“Finish what? I was kidding around. Everybody knew that.”

He looked toward the cooler. The eight relatives who’d been his audience stood where they’d stood before. None of them helped him.

“Come on,” he said. “You all laughed.”

Desmond set the broom against the fence.

“I did,” he said.

Darren pointed at him, grateful.

“There. See?”

“I shouldn’t have.”

My brother’s hand fell.

Mom moved between the chairs, her napkin clenched in one fist.

“Tara, honey. It’s been a long day. Let’s have Nana’s cake.”

I wanted to agree. I could almost feel the car keys in my pocket, the familiar relief of leaving before anybody had to admit anything.

Then Darren said, “Exactly. Let’s not wreck her birthday.”

Nana pushed herself up from her chair.

At eighty-one, getting to her feet took planning. She set both hands on the arms, leaned forward, and refused Mom’s offered elbow. Everyone waited.

“My birthday can stand ten minutes,” she said.

Darren’s face reddened.

“I didn’t mean anything by it.”

“Then this should be easy,” I said. “Tell me you’re sorry.”

“I am sorry if you took it wrong.”

“No.”

“What do you want me to say?”

“What you did.”

He rubbed the back of his neck.

“You want a speech? You want me to stand here and tell everyone you’re some war hero? Fine. You are. Apparently you are. I didn’t know.”

“Leave Hollis’s son out of your apology.”

That stopped him.

My throat hurt. I hadn’t planned to say that much.

“I could have filed papers in Georgia for twenty years,” I said. “You still don’t get to put your fist in my face.”

Darren looked at Mom.

“Mom, say something.”

She started with my name.

I stood up.

There was enough room between us now that nobody had to step aside. Hollis remained in his chair. Nana stayed on her feet.

“Don’t ask me to make this comfortable for him,” I said.

Mom’s eyes filled.

“I wasn’t going to.”

“You were.”

She opened her mouth, then pressed the napkin against it.

Darren gave a short laugh. Nobody followed.

“Oh, so now we’re all terrible people because I made a joke.”

I bent to retrieve my lemonade. My hand shook enough that I left it where it was.

“Since ten after one,” I said.

He looked away.

“You asked about my money. My job. Whether I had a gun. You kept coming back.”

“Because you wouldn’t talk to anybody.”

“I talked to Nana.”

“You know what I mean. You sit there like you’re better than us.”

There it was. The complaint underneath all his questions.

I’d driven two hours carrying banana pudding. Apparently I’d done it in a superior manner.

“I was sitting in a lawn chair, Darren.”

A cousin made a sound, then stopped. I didn’t want laughter going the other way either. I wanted my brother to stand in the quiet he’d made.

He picked up his beer, found it nearly empty, and put it back.

“I just wanted you to loosen up.”

“By laughing at her?” Mom said.

Darren stared at her.

“You laughed too.”

Her shoulders dropped.

“Yes,” she said. “I did.”

She faced me.

“I kept waiting for you to laugh so I could pretend it was all right.”

I couldn’t answer her yet.

She lowered the napkin.

“I’m sorry, Tara.”

Darren rubbed his palms down his jeans.

“Okay. All right. I took it too far.”

I waited.

He looked around the yard once more. Thirty-one people, including him, and he couldn’t find anybody willing to hand him the old script.

His face worked. He hated this. I knew him well enough to know that.

He also stayed.

“I kept making fun of you,” he said. “You weren’t laughing, and I kept doing it.”

His eyes met mine for barely a second.

“Putting my fist up like that was wrong. I’m sorry.”

I took a breath.

“Don’t do it again.”

“I won’t.”

Nana reached for her chair, and Hollis helped steady it while she sat. Darren moved toward her automatically, then stopped when she raised her hand.

“Not yet,” she said.

He went still.

“You were fixing to make a toast before the cake. You can leave that to somebody else.”

“Nana.”

“I don’t want another performance.”

Darren looked toward the cooler again. His audience had become a group of relatives waiting for him to behave. It was a considerable demotion.

He took his beer to the trash.

I sat down before my knees made the decision for me.

Mom reached toward my shoulder.

“May I?”

I nodded. Her hand rested there, light enough that I could move away.

Hollis held his phone between his palms.

“I owe you an apology too,” he said. “I made a spectacle.”

“You dropped a jar.”

“I could’ve asked privately.”

I glanced toward Nana.

She was looking at me with tears running down her face, and she wasn’t doing a thing to hide them.

“Nana?”

She held out her hand.

“I knew, baby.”

Nana’s Porch Light

I took her hand, but I didn’t sit beside her yet.

“You knew about his son?”

“Not whose boy he was. Not until Hollis said it.”

She tugged gently until I moved closer.

“I knew about the wall. I knew what they called you.”

Hollis leaned forward.

“June?”

Nana looked at him.

“Roy told me what Tara told him. She gave him permission to tell me. Nobody else.”

Grandpa had been good at sitting without filling the air. I’d given him pieces over the years. He never asked for a more exciting version.

“I thought you meant you knew I had a bad day,” I said.

“He told me what you wanted me to know.”

I sank into the chair beside her.

“Why didn’t you say something today?”

The question hurt her. I could see it land.

She rubbed her thumb across my knuckles.

“I should have stopped your brother before you had to. I thought if I got you to stay, he’d settle down and we’d have a good evening.”

She shook her head.

“I’ve lived eighty-one years. You’d think I’d be done making that mistake.”

“You don’t have to tell people what I did.”

“I know. I could have told him to shut his mouth without saying another word about you.”

Hollis turned his phone over.

“Roy knew my boy got buried in that collapse,” he said. “I told him years ago. But I don’t think I ever used the call sign with him. Just said we were trying to find the soldier who reached him.”

Nana nodded.

“He wouldn’t have matched up what he didn’t know.”

For sixteen years, the connection had been sitting somewhere between a deer stand and Nana’s kitchen. It took my brother being an ass to drag it into the yard.

I wasn’t about to thank Darren for his contribution.

Nana squeezed my fingers.

“Would you have come if I’d told you Hollis might ask about your service?”

“Probably not.”

“That’s why I didn’t ask you to give a speech. I wanted my granddaughter at my birthday.”

“You got rather more than you ordered.”

“I generally do with this family.”

I laughed. It came out wet and ugly, and Nana pulled my head against her shoulder like I was still small enough to fit there.

The tears arrived then. I hated the timing. I’d held myself together through the whole awful afternoon, and my grandmother’s sleeve undid me.

She patted my back.

Nobody applauded. Thank God. I could have survived enemy fire and still died of being clapped at in a lawn chair.

When I sat up, Hollis offered a clean handkerchief.

“Old man equipment,” he said.

“Better than the napkins. Those dissolve if you think about water.”

He smiled.

Behind us, Darren approached with the dustpan. He’d found another piece of glass under the smoker.

He stopped a few feet away.

“I checked around the chairs too.”

“Thank you,” Nana said.

He nodded, looking at me.

“I meant what I said.”

“I heard you.”

For once, he accepted the answer without demanding a better one.

Desmond brought out the cake. Aunt Jeanette followed with candles, and Mom took the plates from her so she could sit.

Nobody handed Darren the floor.

Nana asked Hollis to say a few words about Roy, and he managed exactly one.

“Miss him.”

“So do I,” she said. “Now somebody light those before I turn eighty-two.”

We sang. I wasn’t the only person on key, but Nana looked straight at me as though she’d booked professional entertainment.

Darren stayed behind Mom. He sang without adding a joke.

After the candles, while the cake was being cut, Hollis stood beside my chair.

“Could I give my son your number?”

“Ask him first.”

“He’ll say yes.”

“Ask him anyway.”

Hollis nodded.

“I will.”

He offered his hand again. This time I stood and hugged him.

He held on carefully, and I held on harder.

By the time people began carrying chairs toward the shed, I had stopped checking the hour. Darren carried the ones I’d been about to pick up. Mom collected plates without asking me to help her disappear into the kitchen.

I took Nana’s Pyrex inside instead. There was barely enough pudding left to bother keeping, which had never stopped Nana in her life.

She followed me to the sink.

“Leave it,” she said.

“It’ll set like concrete.”

“Then we’ll get Hollis. He’s acquainted with someone who digs.”

I turned toward her.

She looked worried for half a second.

Then I laughed so hard I had to brace myself against the counter.

Nana laughed with me. No audience. No one waiting to see whether I could take it.

Later, I carried the washed dish to the porch. Nana came beside me and switched on the light. Beyond the fence, Hollis’s gray pickup pulled away.

My keys were in my hand again.

“You could stay,” Nana said.

I looked at her.

“Guest bed still squeak?”

“Only if you move.”

“Excellent accommodations.”

She reached for the Pyrex. I kept it and opened the door for her.

At the threshold, she slipped her hand into mine.

“Come on, Tara. I’ll find you a towel.”

Family gatherings can reveal more than anyone expects – much like the moments in “My Husband Sat Below the Nursery Window and Held Out His Arms” and “My Son Left His Hospital Sticker on My Passenger Seat”. And for another family story with a mystery at its center, read “My Sister Kept Her Car Keys Beside My Son’s Casts”.