My Neighbor’s Husband Waited Upstairs While We Drank Wine

My garage broom was still leaning against the freezer when I left with Noreen. I remember that because, afterward, I kept thinking how pleasant an evening with dust and dead moths would have been.

Last Friday, my next-door neighbor appeared with a bottle of Pinot and a smile that kept slipping at the corners. Curtis, her husband, was away for work, she told me. She wanted company.

His work trips seemed to line up with her invitations. I assumed she got lonely. I had no plans beyond the garage, and it had been months since I’d enjoyed a girls’ night.

We took our glasses into her backyard. As the sun went down, the solar lights began blinking awake around the fence.

Noreen drank faster than I did.

Soon she was talking about money and the things Curtis wouldn’t tell her. Then she gave a little laugh.

“Curtis keeps his second phone in the glove box.”

I barely knew the man well enough to picture his first phone.

About an hour into the visit, I went inside to use the bathroom. Footsteps crossed the floor above me.

When I came out, Noreen was in the kitchen with the bottle.

“You sure Curtis isn’t home?”

Her hand stopped over her glass. Then came that smile again, followed by a vague explanation about him possibly returning early.

I picked up my purse. I said I had an early shift Saturday, which was true, although I would have invented a job on the spot if necessary.

Before I reached the front door, Curtis appeared on the stairs.

He was shirtless, with a towel around his waist. He looked straight at me without a flicker of surprise.

Then he grinned and opened his mouth.

The Bottom Stair

“So, did she tell you what kind of evening we’re having?”

I kept my purse over my shoulder.

“What kind are you having, Curtis?”

He came down another step. Noreen stood behind me, close enough that I could hear her breathing.

“Come on. We’re all adults.”

That sentence has never once improved a situation for me.

“I came over for wine with your wife.”

“Right. And now I’m home.”

He spread his hands as though he had supplied the missing ingredient.

I looked at Noreen.

“What did you tell him?”

She put her glass on the hall cabinet. It missed the coaster and left a wet ring. For some reason, she rubbed at it with her thumb.

“Noreen.”

“I didn’t tell him you would.”

Curtis’s grin tightened.

“Don’t do this now.”

“Would what?” I said.

He answered before she could.

“Join us. Spend some time upstairs. Nobody’s asking you to sign a contract.”

There it was. Plain enough that I couldn’t soften it later, no matter how much I wanted my neighbor back.

I turned fully toward Noreen.

“You invited me here for that?”

Her eyes filled.

“He said I could ask. I said I didn’t think you would be interested.”

“You said she’d been on her own a while,” Curtis said.

I stared at him.

Apparently, being single had become a standing invitation. Somebody should have warned me when I bought the smaller carton of milk.

“I didn’t ask her,” Noreen said. “I couldn’t.”

“So you thought you’d get a few glasses into her first?”

She shook her head hard.

“No. No, I thought if we just stayed outside, he’d give up.”

Curtis let out a laugh.

“Now I’m some monster because my wife suggested a little fun.”

“You suggested it,” she said.

He looked at her then. Really looked at her. The smile disappeared.

My hand tightened around my purse strap.

“Move away from the door, Curtis.”

He was standing between me and the latch. Not touching it. Not touching me. Just taking up the space and expecting the rest of us to arrange ourselves around him.

“You’re making this unpleasant.”

“Yes. Imagine.”

He stayed where he was.

I took out my phone.

“I’m going home. You can step aside, or I can call for help while you explain why I can’t.”

He moved.

I opened the door but didn’t cross the threshold. Noreen had pressed herself against the cabinet.

“Do you want to come outside with me?”

Curtis answered.

“She’s fine.”

“I asked Noreen.”

She looked from my face to the dark space beyond the door.

“Could I?”

“Get your shoes.”

He pulled the towel tighter.

“This is ridiculous. She invited you. Don’t come into my home and start acting like you’re rescuing her.”

“I am leaving your home. She can leave it too.”

Noreen’s sandals were beneath the cabinet. She bent to pick them up, then stood holding them instead of putting them on.

Curtis took a step toward her.

“Noreen. Tell her whose idea this was.”

She flinched. I wanted to reach for her, but I kept my hand on the door. She had enough people deciding what her body should do that evening.

Finally she said, “The invitation was mine.”

Curtis lifted his chin.

“There.”

“But I didn’t want this.”

His mouth opened.

I cut across him.

“Put some clothes on before you follow us.”

Noreen came through the doorway carrying her sandals. We walked across his front path and onto mine. I didn’t touch her until we reached my porch.

Then I took her elbow because her knees were shaking.

Inside my house, I locked the door. The garage broom was visible through the open utility-room doorway, still awaiting my return like the evening’s most sensible companion.

Noreen sat on the edge of my sofa.

“I’m so sorry.”

I put a glass of water in front of her.

“Was he upstairs when you knocked on my door?”

She nodded.

I sat opposite her.

That hurt more than the towel. Curtis had been revolting, but Curtis wasn’t the woman who brought my trash bin up when my back went out.

“You knew.”

“Yes.”

“And you told me he was away.”

“Yes.”

She covered her mouth.

I waited. I wasn’t going to supply an excuse she could borrow.

“He told me I keep saying no to everything,” she said. “That I make him feel old. That other wives wouldn’t be so uptight.”

“That still doesn’t explain inviting me.”

“I thought you’d say no. Then he’d stop asking me.”

“You didn’t ask me.”

“I know.”

“You let me walk into it without a choice.”

Her face crumpled.

For a minute there was only the sound of her crying and my refrigerator making the expensive noise I’d been ignoring.

I wanted to comfort her. I also wanted to send her home. Both feelings sat there, and neither was polite enough to leave.

Then her phone began ringing.

Curtis’s name filled the screen.

Noreen reached for it automatically.

“Wait,” I said. “Do you want to answer him?”

Her hand stopped.

“No.”

“Then don’t.”

She stared at the ringing phone until it fell silent.

Noreen’s Phone

A message appeared almost immediately.

Noreen read it, closed her eyes, and passed the phone to me.

Tell her you misunderstood. I’m not having the whole street think I’m a creep because you couldn’t explain a simple invitation.

I gave it back.

“He can survive my opinion.”

“He’ll say I set him up.”

“He just did.”

She put both feet on the floor. Her sandals were still in her lap.

I went into the kitchen for a cloth because she’d spilled water down her wrist. When I returned, she was trying to buckle a sandal with fingers that wouldn’t cooperate.

“Where are you going?”

“Home. I have to sort this out.”

“Tonight?”

“If I leave it, he’ll get angrier.”

I sat beside her, leaving space between us.

“Has he hurt you?”

“No.”

“Are you afraid he will?”

She took so long to answer that I stopped looking for a quick one.

“I’m afraid of what he’ll say until I agree with him.”

Her phone rang again.

She turned it facedown.

“He has this way of going over things. By the end, I’m apologizing, and I can’t remember how we started.”

I thought about the money conversation in the backyard. Each time she’d got close to saying something definite, she’d made a joke and swallowed more wine.

“What about the second phone?”

“It’s his. I found it when I was looking for the insurance card in the car. He said it was for work.”

“Do you believe him?”

“No.”

She rubbed the strap of her sandal between her fingers.

“He said tonight would prove I trusted him. That I wasn’t some jealous wife checking up on him.”

I wanted to give Curtis my opinion of his proof. Preferably through a megaphone outside his bedroom window.

Instead, I asked, “Who can you stay with?”

“My sister. Beth.”

“Does she know any of this?”

Noreen shook her head.

“What would happen if you called her?”

“She’d come.”

There was such certainty in that answer that I almost cried myself.

“Then call.”

Noreen found Beth’s number but held her thumb above it.

“What do I say?”

“The part you don’t want to say.”

She pressed the screen.

I moved to the kitchen while she spoke. Not far enough away to miss it if she needed me, far enough that she didn’t have to perform her humiliation for another audience.

“Could you come get me?” she said.

Then, after a pause, “I’m next door.”

Another pause.

“No. I don’t want to sleep at home tonight.”

By the time she ended the call, her shoulders were lower.

“She’s on her way.”

“Good.”

“She asked if I needed clothes.”

“We can get clothes.”

Noreen looked toward the window.

My porch light came on.

Three knocks followed.

Curtis was dressed now. Jeans and a polo shirt. He’d found the costume for a reasonable man remarkably quickly.

I opened the door with the chain still on.

“She’s coming home,” he said.

“No, she’s waiting for Beth.”

He looked over my shoulder.

“Noreen. Seriously?”

She stood behind the sofa.

“I called her.”

“You called your sister over a joke?”

I almost shut the door then. I had an early shift, a headache coming, and no desire to host a man who considered a towel a persuasive argument.

But Noreen came closer.

“I need my bag,” she said. “And my medication.”

“I’ll get it. Then we can talk at home.”

“Beth can come with me.”

His face changed at Beth’s name.

“You’ve told her some version of this already, haven’t you?”

Noreen said nothing.

He turned back to me.

“I don’t know what you think happened, but this was between my wife and me.”

“You invited me into it.”

“I never invited you. She did.”

He said it quickly, with satisfaction.

Noreen’s eyes dropped.

There was the place he meant to put us: her defending herself to me, me angry with her, him standing outside the mess in his clean polo.

I was angry with her. I wasn’t going to let him spend that anger on his own escape.

“She lied to me,” I said. “You waited upstairs for a woman who hadn’t agreed to anything.”

“You could have said no.”

“I did. You complained.”

He pressed his lips together.

From behind me, Noreen said, “You told me if I wouldn’t even ask, there was no point pretending we still had a marriage.”

Curtis looked at her through the gap.

“Don’t quote half a conversation.”

“Then say the other half,” she said.

He didn’t.

A car pulled up. Beth got out, and Noreen stepped back while I closed the door long enough to remove the chain.

Beth was a compact woman in a cardigan buttoned wrong. She had clearly dressed in a hurry and hadn’t wasted time pretending otherwise.

She walked past Curtis.

“Where’s my sister?”

Noreen came into the doorway.

Beth put both arms around her. Noreen made a sound I’d never heard from her before, and clung to the back of the cardigan.

Curtis waited until Beth loosened her hold.

“Perhaps somebody can explain why we’re turning a private misunderstanding into a family crisis.”

Beth looked at Noreen.

“Do you want him here?”

Noreen wiped her face with her sleeve.

“I want my things. Then I want to go.”

Curtis gave a short laugh.

“After everything I’ve put up with, you’re leaving with your sister because your friend can’t take a compliment?”

Noreen straightened.

“She wasn’t invited here for you.”

He pointed toward his house.

“Then come back and say that inside.”

Noreen looked at me.

“Will you come?”

I picked up my keys.

The Glass on the Cabinet

We crossed the two front paths together, with Beth beside Noreen and me behind them. Curtis went ahead and opened his door.

The wineglass still stood on the hall cabinet. The ring beneath it had dried.

Noreen stopped beside it.

Curtis headed into the living room, but she didn’t follow.

“My bag is upstairs.”

“Can we sit down like adults first?”

“No,” she said.

He turned.

For the first time that evening, he looked uncertain about where everyone would stand.

Beth stayed by the stairs.

“Go get what you need. I’ll come with you.”

Noreen looked at Curtis.

“Don’t follow us.”

He threw out his hands.

“It’s my bedroom too.”

“Then wait ten minutes.”

The two women went upstairs. I stayed by the open front door.

Curtis looked me over.

“I suppose you’re pleased.”

“No. I was promised Pinot.”

He didn’t smile.

“You’ve known her a few years. I’ve lived with her for decades. You have no idea what she can be like.”

“I know what you were like an hour ago.”

“She talks about our marriage to everyone. She makes me sound awful, then wonders why I’m frustrated.”

I said nothing.

“Do you honestly believe I would have come downstairs like that if she hadn’t led me to expect something?”

“I believe you came downstairs without checking with me.”

He looked away.

Overhead, a drawer opened.

I wanted to leave. I wanted my own house, my own lock, the ordinary irritation of remembering I hadn’t put the laundry away.

But Noreen had asked me to stay, and this time she’d actually asked.

Curtis lowered his voice.

“Look, I’m sorry you felt uncomfortable.”

“You blocked the door.”

“I moved.”

“When I took out my phone.”

He dragged a hand across his mouth.

“What do you want from me?”

“Nothing.”

That seemed to bother him more than a demand would have.

Beth and Noreen came down with a small suitcase. Noreen carried her handbag and a bottle of medication. She’d washed her face upstairs, but her eyes were still red.

Curtis moved toward the suitcase.

“You’re really doing this?”

Beth kept hold of the handle.

Noreen stood beside me.

“I’m staying with Beth.”

“For how long?”

“I haven’t decided.”

He looked at Beth, then at me.

“So this is what we’re doing? You two get to vote on my marriage?”

Beth said, “I came to collect my sister.”

Curtis turned to Noreen.

“Tell her you invited the neighbor. Tell your sister that much.”

“I invited her,” Noreen said.

“And you discussed it with me beforehand.”

“You told me to ask her.”

“And you agreed.”

“I agreed to ask. Then I couldn’t. I should have told her you were home. I should have canceled.”

He nodded sharply, as though she’d reached the correct answer on a test.

“Exactly.”

Noreen faced me.

“I used you to put off telling him no. I’m sorry. You trusted me.”

I swallowed.

“Yes, I did.”

She took that without looking away.

Curtis put his hands on his hips.

“Fine. We’ve established she handled it badly. Can everybody go home now?”

Beth’s mouth opened, but Noreen spoke first.

“I didn’t want anyone upstairs with us. I told you that before I knocked on her door.”

“That’s not how I remember it.”

“You said I’d get used to the idea.”

“I said you might enjoy yourself if you stopped deciding everything was disgusting.”

Beth set the suitcase upright.

Curtis looked at her face and stopped.

Noreen reached for her bag.

“There. That’s the part you wanted me to leave out.”

He stepped closer.

“Noreen, please. We can talk about this without them.”

“No.”

“We’ve been married too long for you to walk out over one bad evening.”

She began crying again. She didn’t move toward him.

“I know how long we’ve been married.”

His face softened, or arranged itself to look soft. I couldn’t tell anymore.

“Then stay. I’ll apologize to her properly. We’ll forget this happened.”

I shook my head.

“You don’t get to promise that for me.”

He looked at me with open dislike.

“You were never going to do anything you didn’t want to do.”

“Neither is she.”

Noreen took the suitcase handle from Beth.

Curtis’s eyes filled. Whether it was shame, panic, or the sight of his wife holding luggage, I didn’t know.

“I said I’m sorry.”

“No,” Noreen said. “You haven’t said it to me.”

For a moment, he looked ready to argue about the exact words.

Then he said, “I’m sorry I pushed you.”

She waited.

“And I’m sorry I came downstairs when you hadn’t asked her.”

“You knew I hadn’t,” she said.

His eyes went to Beth.

Noreen held his gaze until he looked back.

“Yes,” he said.

Nobody hurried to make him feel better.

Noreen rolled the suitcase to the door.

Curtis reached for my arm as I followed her. I stepped away before his hand landed.

“Can’t you at least tell her I didn’t mean any harm?”

“You can explain yourself.”

I went out and closed his door.

My Side of the Fence

Beth opened the car’s trunk while Noreen stood beside me on the pavement.

“I’m not asking you to forgive me tonight,” she said.

“Good. I can’t.”

She nodded. Tears slid down her face again, and she wiped them away with the heel of her hand.

“Can I let you know I got there?”

“Yes.”

Beth put the suitcase in the trunk. Then she came over and held out my keys, which I’d left on the hall cabinet while the women were upstairs.

“Figured you might want to get into your own house.”

I took them.

“That would improve the evening.”

She smiled, briefly.

Noreen got into the passenger seat. Before Beth closed the door, she leaned out.

“I really did want a night with my friend.”

“You could have had one.”

Her chin trembled.

“I know.”

They drove away. I went inside and checked the lock twice, then stood in the kitchen with both hands against the counter.

I hadn’t cried in front of Curtis. I hadn’t cried when Noreen admitted she knew.

Alone, I cried over the stupid broom.

I’d gone next door expecting an evening where I didn’t have to be useful or careful. Just two women, a bottle, and some gossip about whose hedge was getting out of hand.

I put the broom away without cleaning the garage.

Noreen’s message arrived before I went to bed.

I’m at Beth’s. Thank you for staying.

I wrote back that I was glad she’d arrived.

Nothing more. It was all I had.

On Saturday, I went to my early shift. When I came home, Curtis was in his driveway. He raised a hand.

I kept walking.

He called my name once.

I turned.

“If this is about Noreen, call Noreen.”

“I just want things to be normal.”

“Then you should have behaved normally.”

That was our last conversation.

Noreen stayed with Beth. The following Friday, she asked whether she could visit me for ten minutes. She said she would understand if I wasn’t ready.

I let her come to the porch.

She brought no wine, no flowers, no apology gift to make me feel obliged. Just herself.

“I told Curtis I’m not coming back while I decide what I want,” she said.

“How did he take it?”

“He said people would talk.”

She gave a tired laugh.

“That was his first concern. Not whether I was sleeping. Not whether I wanted to see him.”

I moved over on the porch bench.

She sat.

“I told Beth everything,” she said. “Including what I did to you. I didn’t let her make it all his fault.”

I rubbed a rough spot on the bench with my thumb.

“Thank you.”

“I miss you.”

“I miss you too. I’m still angry.”

“I know.”

She stayed ten minutes. She didn’t ask me to call Curtis, carry messages, or tell her she’d done nothing wrong.

When she left, I hugged her. Briefly, but I meant it.

It took longer than a hug.

Over the next few months, Noreen rented a place near Beth and began ending her marriage. She told me about those decisions after making them, which I appreciated. I could be her friend. I wasn’t qualified to be the steering wheel.

Curtis lost the wife he expected to smooth over his behavior. He also lost access to my porch, my company, and the comfortable fiction that Friday had been a joke between willing adults.

Noreen and I didn’t start where we’d left off.

Sometimes I said no to an invitation. She accepted it without a second question. That helped more than the apologies.

One evening, months after that Friday, she came over while I was finally clearing the garage.

She stood in the doorway with two bottles of lemonade.

“Just me,” she said.

“I can see that.”

“I thought I’d say it anyway.”

I took one bottle and handed her the broom.

“You’ve arrived at an unfortunate time.”

She looked at the dusty floor.

“Do I get a glass first?”

“Your standards are getting very high.”

We worked until the floor was clear enough to walk across without turning sideways. Then we carried two chairs into my backyard.

My solar lights began coming on along the fence. Noreen sat with her lemonade between her hands.

After a while, she said, “Can I stay a little longer?”

I pulled the other chair closer.

“Yes. You can.”

For more unsettling surprises and family twists, read about what was hiding beneath a little deer’s feet, a birthday surprise that changed everything, and the strange warning behind a little boy’s bedtime ritual.