My Ex-Husband Made Our Daughter Listen To His Joke

I tucked the swimsuit tag inside my neckline before answering the door. It scratched, but taking the suit off meant admitting I wouldn’t swim.

Wes arrived at 11:40 that Labor Day morning. At 36, he looked like somebody you could bring anywhere. At 42, I apparently needed to hire that sort of person.

Seventeen years earlier, I’d married Jeremiah at 25. In February, over our running dishwasher, he’d announced another woman, examined the 38 pounds I’d gained after having Nate, and said, “You’re not who I married anymore, Kim.”

By July, we were divorced. His office manager, Bethany, was 32. My dental-hygienist wages supported my new household while she posted pictures of his boots and called attention to the life she’d stepped into. He advertised his second chance even from my boss’s dental chair.

Marlene, his mother, invited me on Saturday, August 29. She was 71 and still called every Sunday. Three days later, I offered an actor listed as Wes O. $250 to accompany me. He declined payment that night but accepted the invitation.

No money changed hands.

During the 50-minute drive to Indian Lake, he practiced Dominic, Erica and Nate: fourteen, eleven and five.

We arrived around 12:30, half an hour after the party began. Twenty-five people, including us. Hank, 74, guarded his grill. The children were swimming.

Jeremiah refused Wes’s handshake, then said, “Come on. What’s she PAYING you?”

Erica stood behind him in a towel as he invited everyone to compare Wes’s looks with mine.

Wes said he’d come unpaid. Bethany avoided his eyes and retreated to Hank’s dock. Ten minutes later, Wes followed.

I stopped at the shore. Jeremiah came up behind me.

“Hello, Bethany Ostrander.”

Her cup dropped into the lake. She pushed past Wes, crying, and ran into the house.

Jeremiah demanded to know who Ostrander was.

At the last board, Wes stopped without answering.

The Name At The Water

I set both cups on the grass. My fingers had squeezed a dent into one.

“Wes. Tell me.”

He turned toward me first.

“Ostrander is my last name. Bethany is my wife.”

Jeremiah made a noise through his nose, almost a laugh.

“No. She’s divorced.”

“We’re separated. She left in May last year. The divorce hasn’t happened.”

Sixteen months. I counted them without wanting to. Last May, I’d still been folding Jeremiah’s undershirts with the seams tucked inside because he liked them that way.

“You’re sure?” I said.

“We married six years ago. She was twenty-six. I was thirty. She never signed the papers I sent her. We’re still legally married.”

Jeremiah shoved his hands into his pockets, then took them out.

“She told me it was finished.”

Wes looked toward the house.

“Then she lied.”

There it was, out on the grass beside my abandoned lemonade. No dramatic envelope. No lawyer stepping out of the hydrangeas. Just a husband Jeremiah hadn’t known existed.

“And you knew?” I said.

Wes faced me.

“Your booking note named her and Jeremiah’s agency. I recognized her. That’s why I said no charge.”

I wanted to slap him. Mostly because, for fifty minutes in my car, he’d asked me questions as though I were the person he’d come to see.

“You could have told me before I put you in my car.”

“Yes.”

“You let me stand here thinking you were helping me.”

“I thought I could do both.”

“Well, you can’t.”

His mouth tightened. He didn’t reach for my hand again.

Jeremiah pointed between us.

“So this whole thing was planned.”

“No,” I said.

“Come on, Kim. You expect me to believe you accidentally brought her husband?”

“I expect you to hear an answer the first time.”

Marlene came down the lawn. Erica followed her, holding the towel under her chin. Beyond them, Dominic had Nate by the hand in the shallows.

“Erica,” I said, “will you sit with your brothers for a minute?”

“Are we leaving?”

“Not unless you want to.”

She looked at her father, then back at me.

“I don’t want to.”

“Then we’re staying.”

Jeremiah started toward the house. I moved with him.

“This is between me and Bethany,” he said.

“You made me part of it in front of your daughter.”

Wes stayed behind until I turned.

“You too. You owe me the rest where she can hear it.”

Marlene took the towel from Erica’s shoulders and wrapped it properly around her. Such a small thing. I nearly cried over a towel while two marriages lay in the yard like broken lawn chairs.

By the porch steps, Bethany opened the screen door. Her phone was in her hand. She’d wiped her cheeks, but a stripe of makeup remained beside her nose.

“Jeremiah, can we go?”

“Are you married?”

She looked past him.

“Wes, you shouldn’t be here.”

“Answer me,” Jeremiah said.

“We’ve been apart for ages.”

“Are you married?”

“Technically.”

Hank came up from the grill and stopped beside Marlene. Behind us, the sixteen cousins and neighbors remained on the lawn. Nobody made a useful pretense of doing anything else.

Jeremiah put a hand against the porch post.

“You told me your divorce was done before we got together.”

“I didn’t want to keep talking about him. It was over. I wasn’t living with him.”

Wes stayed on the grass.

“You told him something false.”

“You do events for money,” she said. “Don’t stand there pretending this wasn’t a performance.”

“I accepted because your name was in her request. I should have told Kim.”

Bethany looked at me then. Properly, for the first time that afternoon.

“You hired my husband to pretend to be your boyfriend?”

It sounded even worse with her saying it. There are sentences a woman should never have to hear beside a cooler full of orange soda.

“Yes,” I said. “Without knowing he was your husband.”

Jeremiah seized on that.

“So you admit it.”

“Yes.”

“You brought a fake date.”

“Yes.”

He waited for my face to crumble. I could feel the old habit trying to help him: explain, apologize, make it easier for everybody.

Instead, I picked a blade of grass from my sandal.

Bethany stepped down onto the porch.

“Can we please stop doing this outside?”

Jeremiah looked at his mother. She didn’t move toward him.

Wes said, “I’ll arrange the divorce through my lawyer. I don’t need another conversation about whether you intend to come back.”

“Fine,” Bethany said.

“Good.”

He stepped away from the path. She was free to walk past him, just as she’d been free to leave sixteen months before.

Jeremiah turned to me.

“I hope you’re satisfied. You got your little scene.”

I looked toward the shore. Erica was sitting between her brothers, staring up at us.

“No,” I said. “You still haven’t answered for yours.”

Erica’s Towel

Jeremiah spread his hands toward the lawn.

“What do you want me to do, Kim? Stand here while you tell everybody I’m a terrible person?”

“I want you to apologize for what you said about me.”

“I made a joke.”

“Then explain it.”

He looked at Hank, who folded his arms. His father still held the spatula. Even now, apparently nobody else could be trusted with the hamburgers.

Jeremiah tried again.

“You arrived with some man hanging all over you. I was surprised. I said something. Now we find out you actually hired him, and somehow I’m the villain?”

“You told people to look at him and then look at me.”

“I didn’t mean anything by it.”

“Explain the joke.”

Bethany stood beside the porch steps. She slid her phone into her bag and folded her arms too, as though she’d purchased a ticket to a different argument.

Jeremiah lowered his voice.

“Can we discuss this privately?”

“You didn’t need privacy to say it.”

Marlene wiped her palms on her trousers.

“Your daughter heard you.”

“Mom, please. Don’t start.”

“I should have stopped you properly when you said it.”

“You said my name.”

“And then I let you keep talking.”

Her eyes were wet. Mine followed, which annoyed me. I’d hoped to get through at least one entire confrontation without my nose joining in.

Jeremiah rubbed his forehead.

“I’ve had a pretty significant shock here. Can anybody acknowledge that? I’ve just found out the woman I’m with lied to me.”

Bethany’s arms fell.

“You knew I was separated.”

“You said divorced.”

“Because you wouldn’t stop asking about him.”

Wes took a step backward. Whatever answer he’d wanted from her, he’d heard it.

Jeremiah looked at me again.

“You understand what this feels like.”

I almost laughed. Not because it was funny.

“Yes.”

He waited.

That was all I gave him.

For seventeen years, I would have filled that silence with something he could use. I’d have told him he couldn’t have known, that he was still a good man, that everybody made mistakes. I knew the work. I could do it while loading a dishwasher.

He took a breath.

“Things between us weren’t good for a long time.”

“Then you could have left without making my body the reason.”

“You keep coming back to that.”

“I was there.”

Bethany stared at the ground.

I hadn’t come to the lake intending to say that in front of anybody. I’d come wearing a swimsuit under a dress and a stranger on my arm, hoping for one photograph where I looked wanted.

Now my hands shook so badly I tucked them behind my back.

Jeremiah glanced at the lawn again. One cousin who’d laughed earlier put his drink down.

“That was a lousy thing to say,” the cousin said.

Jeremiah’s face changed. He could fight me. He’d practiced. Losing the audience was harder.

“Oh, everybody’s perfect now.”

“No,” I said. “I hired a pretend boyfriend because I was afraid to come alone. That was foolish. Wes used the invitation to confront his wife. That was unfair to me. None of that put those words in your mouth.”

Wes nodded once.

“I owe you an apology, Kim. I used what you told me instead of being honest with you.”

“You do.”

“I’m sorry.”

I didn’t tell him it was fine.

Erica stood up by the shore. Dominic put his hand on her elbow, but she shook her head and came toward us.

I moved down the lawn to meet her.

“You don’t have to be here for this, sweetheart.”

“Did you really hire him?”

“Yes.”

Her mouth pulled to one side.

“Because Dad said that stuff?”

“Because I let myself believe it. I’m sorry you had to hear any of this.”

She looked over my shoulder.

“Dad, why was it funny?”

Jeremiah opened his mouth. Shut it.

“Erica, adults sometimes say things they shouldn’t.”

“But why was Mom the funny part?”

He looked down at her towel, the one Marlene had tucked around her, and bent his knees a little.

“She shouldn’t have been.”

“Then why did you do it?”

He straightened. His eyes moved to me, as if I could supply a softer question.

I stayed where I was.

“Because I wanted to embarrass her,” he said.

The words carried far enough. He didn’t have to shout.

Erica pressed her face into my side. I put my arm around her shoulders.

Jeremiah swallowed.

“I’m sorry, Kim. What I said was cruel. You didn’t deserve it.”

I nodded. I wasn’t going to applaud him for finally naming what everyone had heard.

Bethany reached for his wrist.

“Can we leave now?”

He pulled away.

“I’m not taking you home. I need to be by myself.”

She stared at him, then drew out her phone. Her second-chance afternoon was ending with a ride request beside the begonias.

Jeremiah looked at me once more.

“I didn’t think it would get this bad.”

“You thought I’d leave.”

He had no answer.

The Swimsuit Under My Dress

Hank lifted his chin toward the driveway.

“Take a walk with me, son.”

Jeremiah hesitated. Then he followed his father along the side of the house.

Bethany stayed near the porch, looking at her phone. Marlene stood beside me until Erica loosened her grip.

“Do you want to go home?” Marlene said.

I looked down at my daughter.

“Do you?”

“Dominic said he’d take me back to the raft.”

“Then go.”

Erica started toward the shore, stopped, and came back for a hug that nearly folded me in half. Eleven is an awkward age for needing your mother in public. She held on anyway.

When she left, I sat on the bottom porch step.

My legs had apparently resigned while the rest of me was busy.

Marlene sat beside me.

“I’m sorry I invited you into this.”

“You invited me to the lake.”

“I knew he’d bring her.”

“And I knew he’d be here.”

She rubbed a spot on her knee.

“Next time, I won’t stand there saying his name like that fixes anything.”

“Thank you.”

She reached for my hand. Hers was warm and dry. I squeezed it until I could stop holding my breath.

Wes came over but stayed off the porch.

“Would you like me to arrange my own ride?”

“Yes.”

“All right.”

He took out his phone, then paused.

“For what it’s worth, what he said about you was wrong.”

“I know.”

The answer surprised me enough that I looked up.

Wes nodded.

“I’ll wait out front.”

He didn’t ask for my number. He already had it from the booking, but he didn’t make a speech about seeing me again. I was grateful. I had quite enough husbands in circulation for one afternoon.

As he walked around the house, I said, “Wes.”

He turned.

“Next time somebody tells you something embarrassing because they need help, tell them the truth before you show up.”

“I will.”

Bethany’s ride arrived first. She came down the steps with her bag against her ribs and stopped beside me.

“I didn’t know he talked to you like that.”

I looked at her.

“You were standing beside him.”

She started to say something, then pressed her lips together.

I turned back toward the lake.

Her footsteps continued up the path.

Marlene let out a breath through her nose.

“Well,” she said, “the corn’s probably leather.”

I laughed. It came out badly, half a sob, but it was mine.

She put her arm around me until I finished.

Hank returned from the driveway alone. He set the spatula on the grill shelf, which should probably have been recorded for his descendants.

“Jeremiah’s heading home,” he said. “He’ll speak to Dominic before he goes. If Dominic wants to.”

“Thank you.”

“He doesn’t get to run you off this place.”

I rubbed my eyes with the heel of my hand.

“I don’t want the children thinking they have to choose.”

“Neither do I,” Hank said. “But they can hear their father apologize.”

At the shore, Jeremiah waited while Dominic climbed out of the water. I couldn’t hear their conversation. I didn’t move closer.

Dominic kept his arms folded at first. Then he let them drop. Jeremiah put a hand on his shoulder and took it away when Dominic stepped back.

It wasn’t mine to repair for him.

Nate ran up to his father, and Jeremiah crouched to hug him. I let that be theirs too.

When Jeremiah came toward me, I stood.

“I told Dominic I was wrong,” he said.

“Good.”

“I’ll text about pickup.”

“All right.”

He glanced toward the path where Bethany had left, then back at me.

“I really am sorry.”

“Then don’t repeat it.”

He nodded and went to his car.

Wes left in a separate ride a few minutes later. There was no handsome-man ending waiting behind the house. I had my car keys, my children, and the same body I’d arrived in.

It was enough to work with.

I carried the cups from the grass to the trash, then returned to the shore. Dominic and Erica were halfway to the raft. Nate stood beside Marlene, pushing his toes into the mud.

“Mom, come in.”

I looked down at my dress.

For years I’d had a useful excuse ready. Somebody needed sunscreen. Somebody might want a drink. I could find a job beside any body of water in North America.

Marlene held out her hand.

“I’ll take your dress.”

“You’re awfully sure.”

“He’s asked you three times since you got here.”

I pulled it over my head before I could invent a reason not to. The swimsuit tag scratched my neck.

Marlene folded the dress over her arm.

Nate grinned at me like I’d brought a pony.

I took his hand and stepped into Indian Lake. Cold water reached my thighs, then my waist. From the raft, Erica waved both arms.

Dominic cupped his hands around his mouth.

“Mom, you coming out?”

“Give me a minute. Some of us have knees older than you.”

He laughed. Erica laughed. This time I didn’t have to figure out whether I was the joke.

Nate splashed me, delighted with himself. I splashed him back, and he grabbed my shoulders while I held him afloat in his vest.

Behind us, Marlene spread my sundress over the porch rail.

“Again, Mom,” Nate said.

I pushed us away from the shore.

For more family-drama stories about painful exclusions and crossed lines, read the story of a son who left his mother out of Christmas, a father reaching for his grandson’s recovery money, and the wedding-day clash over the bride’s parents.