I had tucked a waste bag into each sneaker before leaving home. That was how determined I was to be a considerate dog owner. By the sixth inning, one sneaker was soaked with lemonade and my dog had stolen a policeman’s supper.
My name is Debra Stroud, Deb to everyone except the insurance companies. At fifty-two, divorced and working reception at a dental office, I needed somewhere to go that wasn’t work or home.
Pups in the Park night at the minor-league ballpark in Rockford seemed safe enough.
That Thursday in July, my six-year-old yellow Lab, Tater, spent five innings accepting ear rubs beside my aisle seat in section 114, row 9. Four years earlier, I’d adopted a skinny two-year-old nobody seemed to want. Now he weighed eighty-one pounds and received compliments on his eyebrows.
Only the season-ticket holder behind us objected. He’d been glaring since the second inning.
Two seats from him, a uniformed officer settled into row 10 with a soda and an $8 chili dog with onions.
With the home team trailing 3-1, I turned to pay the lemonade vendor by card. His reader stalled. Perhaps twenty-two seconds passed.
When I faced forward, Tater held the entire chili dog in his mouth.
I sprang up, splashed my shoes, and offered the officer a twenty, enough for two replacements with four dollars left.
The man behind us stood.
“That’s what you get for bringing a mutt to a ballgame. Somebody get security.”
Four phones pointed our way. Someone suggested arresting Tater. The man complained about a zoo, then claimed my dog might bite a child.
My tugging and pleading accomplished nothing.
An usher hurried down. The officer silenced the heckler with one hand, set his tray aside, and crouched.
Tater placed the food between his boots and sat straight.
The officer turned the rescue tag over.
“Put your money away,” he said. “Where did you get him?”
The notch in his ear
I gave him the rescue’s name. Then, because I was frightened, I gave him considerably more information than he’d requested.
“Four years ago. He was two. I have his adoption papers at home. His shots are current. I brought the paperwork they asked for tonight.”
The officer let the tag fall against Tater’s chest.
“I know that rescue.”
His hand moved to Tater’s left ear. There was a notch along the edge, a little piece missing that I’d always rubbed around without thinking about it.
He folded the ear back gently. Tater pushed his head into his palm.
“How old did you say?”
“Six.”
The officer smiled down at him.
“Well, I’ll be.”
Behind me, the man shifted against his seat cushion.
“What’s the problem?” he said.
The officer kept his hand on Tater.
“No problem. I think I know this dog.”
My fingers tightened around the twenty.
For one horrible second, I thought someone else was coming to collect him. Someone with an earlier claim, an old photograph, a name Tater might like better than the one I used.
The officer looked up.
“He’s yours, ma’am. I’m not questioning that.”
I must have had my fear written across my face in letters big enough for the scoreboard.
“I’m Ray Dominguez,” he said. “I worked with him when he was young.”
“Worked?”
“We started him in the department’s K9 program five years ago. Still a puppy, really. About a year old.”
He rubbed the notch with his thumb.
“This was already there. And that rescue took him when he didn’t work out. I helped take him over.”
I looked at Tater. He was gazing up at Ray with the expression he usually reserved for the drawer where I kept cheese.
“My dog was a police dog?”
“A candidate,” Ray said. “We need to be fair to the police dogs.”
Somebody laughed. This time it didn’t feel aimed at me.
“He washed out at eighteen months,” Ray said. “Bright dog. Friendly. Could find anything we hid.”
“Then why?”
Ray glanced at the chili dog on the concrete.
“He kept stealing food off the handlers’ trays.”
I covered my mouth.
There was a beat of silence, then the woman in row 8 bent forward laughing. The man beside one of the raised phones slapped his knee.
Tater’s tail started again.
“You’re serious?”
“Very. You could work with him all morning, turn your back at lunch, and lose a sandwich. We tried. He had other career plans.”
I laughed so hard my breath caught halfway out. It came back as something dangerously close to a sob.
For four years I’d called that dog my little potato. Apparently, for part of his youth, he’d been a public expense.
Ray scratched under his collar.
“I haven’t seen him since he went to the rescue. He’s filled out.”
“He believes in regular meals.”
“I remember.”
The usher bent down with napkins and picked up the abandoned chili dog. Ray helped him get it into the tray before Tater could reconsider surrendering it.
“Did he swallow any?” Ray asked me.
“I don’t think so. He was holding it like a trophy.”
“Good. Onions aren’t something he needs.”
I checked around Tater’s mouth and pulled him closer to my seat. He tolerated this inspection with the patience of a man being searched after returning stolen property.
The usher’s name badge read LONNIE. Up close, he looked about seventy, and the stairs had left him breathing through his mouth.
“Let me get this cleared,” he said. “Keep him tucked beside you, please. We need the aisle.”
“Of course.”
I shortened the leash and guided Tater into the space at my feet. He followed. Now he followed. Naturally.
Ray stood, keeping a hand on the railing.
I held out the twenty again.
“Please let me replace your dinner.”
“What’s your name?”
“Deb.”
“I put food within reach of a dog on dog night. I’ll survive.”
That was kind, but I didn’t want kindness to erase the part that was mine.
“I should have kept him closer. You still deserve to eat.”
Before Ray could answer, the man in row 10 leaned forward.
“So because you know the dog, we’re all supposed to think this is funny?”
The laughter stopped around us.
He pointed toward Tater.
“What if that had been some kid holding the food? That’s what I’m saying. Everybody’s laughing, and nobody wants to deal with it.”
I lowered the twenty.
My first instinct was to apologize until he ran out of steam. I did that at work with people who believed a delayed cleaning was an attack on their bloodline.
But Tater was sitting against my shin, and the man was pointing at him as if he’d lunged at somebody.
“He took food,” I said. “I am sorry for that. He didn’t threaten anyone.”
The man opened his mouth.
I put my wallet back in my bag.
“And neither did I.”
Phil’s seat cushion
Lonnie straightened with the ruined dinner in his hands.
“Phil, nobody’s being removed for this.”
So the man had a name. Phil. Somehow I’d expected something longer and more official, like Chairman of Everyone Else’s Evening.
Phil Garrity, I learned when he announced his surname as though Lonnie might have forgotten who occupied that seat.
“I’ve had season tickets for years,” he said. “I pay good money. I shouldn’t have to sit here with animals taking people’s food.”
“You bought a ticket for Pups in the Park,” Lonnie said.
“I bought the season.”
“And this game is part of it.”
Phil pressed both hands against his cushion.
“Fine. Fine. But you’re telling me there are no rules?”
“There are rules,” Lonnie said. “She’s moved him out of the aisle. She’s keeping him close. The officer has handled his lunch.”
Ray picked up his soda from row 10.
“My complaint is settled.”
“You didn’t even make one.”
“That’s right.”
Phil looked toward the four phones, then away. All that audience he’d summoned had become inconvenient.
The woman in row 8 lowered hers first.
“I’m sorry,” she said to me. “I started filming because of the hot dog. I didn’t think.”
She looked about thirty-five. Her cheeks had gone pink.
“I’m Marcy Pruett.”
“Deb.”
“Do you want me to delete it?”
“Yes, please.”
I nearly added if you don’t mind. The words came right to the back of my teeth.
Marcy tapped her screen, showed it to me, then cleared the deleted folder too. The other three people lowered their phones. I asked them to remove theirs as well, and each agreed.
My hands were still shaking, but at least they were doing something besides offering money to make me acceptable.
Phil gave a little snort.
“People film everything now. That’s hardly my fault.”
“No,” I said. “You calling him dangerous was yours.”
“I said he could be.”
Ray stepped aside so a spectator could pass. Then he faced Phil without putting a hand on his belt or changing his voice into anything grand.
“You can be upset about the food. Nobody’s stopping you. But you haven’t seen this dog threaten a child.”
“I’m talking about what could happen.”
“You said it while people were filming her.”
Phil pulled his jersey away from his stomach.
“Well, apparently I’m the villain now. The dog gets a reunion, and I’m supposed to apologize for wanting to watch a game.”
I wanted to tell him he could start by turning toward the field. I wanted to say a few things my dentist employers would have preferred I save for the parking lot.
Instead, I pointed to the damp patch on my shoe.
“I’ve apologized for the thing my dog actually did.”
Marcy turned around in her seat.
“She was trying to pay him before you stood up, Phil.”
He looked at her.
She held his gaze.
The next sound was the announcer calling a batter. It had the peculiar effect of reminding all of us there was still a baseball game going on.
Phil sat.
His cushion squeaked beneath him, which I am ashamed to say helped me quite a bit.
He picked at a loose thread on its edge.
“I shouldn’t have said he’d take a kid’s hand off,” he said.
He aimed it toward the field.
“Please look at me,” I said.
That cost me more than the twenty ever could have.
Phil turned.
“I’m sorry I said that about your dog.”
“And called for security,” Marcy said.
Phil exhaled.
“And made a scene.”
I nodded.
“You can stop now.”
He faced the field again.
Ray took a drink of soda. Lonnie held up the tray and headed toward the concourse, finally able to finish the job he’d come down to do.
Marcy reached under her seat for her cap.
“Can we do something nicer with the rest of this inning?”
She dropped a bill into it.
“Hot dogs for the dogs. Plain ones. With their people’s permission.”
I looked down at Tater.
“Oh, he doesn’t need a reward.”
“Then consider it dinner with witnesses,” she said.
Ray laughed.
Marcy passed the cap along row 8. People who had craned their necks to see my disgrace were reaching into pockets. Owners counted their dogs, checked with one another, and passed the cap onward.
I took out my twenty again.
“Two chili dogs,” I told Marcy. “Sixteen dollars. One for Ray, one for me. The other four can go in the cap.”
Ray started to object.
“Please,” I said. “I’d like to buy someone supper without it being an apology.”
He looked at me for a moment.
“All right.”
Marcy separated the sixteen dollars, then counted the cap money with the woman beside her. Together they worked out the order: a plain hot dog for every dog in section 114 whose owner wanted one, with no onions or chili.
Lonnie came back down after disposing of the tray, and Marcy handed him the money and the order. He agreed to arrange it at the concession stand.
As he turned to climb the stairs, Phil held out a bill.
Lonnie stopped.
“For the dogs,” Phil said.
No one cheered. I was glad. A man ought to be allowed to put down his shovel without somebody handing him a marching band.
Lonnie took it.
“Thank you.”
Then he went up the steps, and I sat down without gathering my bag to leave.
Tater rested his chin on my knee.
For the first time since the sixth inning began, I took a sip of lemonade.
It was mostly water.
I drank it anyway.
One bite at a time
Ray stayed at the aisle while we waited for the food, giving passing spectators room.
“Did they call him Tater back then?” I asked.
“They did. Name suited him.”
“I thought he came with it from a previous home.”
“He came with it to us.”
Tater pressed his nose into Ray’s hand. Ray scratched the place behind his ear that made his back foot twitch.
I had wanted the recognition to mean Tater remembered being loved. Now I wanted to ask why remembering had taken so long.
“Did you ever check on him?”
Ray’s fingers slowed.
“I asked the rescue how he was doing. They told me when he got adopted.”
“And that was it?”
“That was it.”
He didn’t invent a story about searching for him. I liked him better for that, though it made me sad in a small place I couldn’t quite reach.
“They said he went to a woman who spent a long time sitting on the floor with him. I figured he’d landed well.”
“That was me.”
“I thought it might be.”
I rubbed Tater’s shoulder.
“I didn’t know what else to do. He kept knocking over the little folding chair.”
Ray laughed.
“Sounds right.”
“He was there a while.”
“I know.”
The words sat between us. Tater leaned against my legs, heavy and warm, unaware that we were discussing the part of his life I wished I could go back and shorten.
“I wish somebody had told me he’d tried police work.”
“Would it have changed your mind?”
“No. But I might have hidden my sandwiches sooner.”
Ray had to turn his head while he laughed.
He told me he was forty-one when I complained that getting up from that rescue floor had been easier four years ago. I told him to enjoy his knees while they still answered on the first request.
Then Lonnie returned with a box.
Marcy stood to help, but someone was coming up the aisle, so Lonnie stepped into row 10 instead. Phil sat nearest the space he needed.
“Here, Phil,” Lonnie said. “Pass these down. One plain one per dog. Let the owners take them.”
Phil looked at the box.
Then he took it onto his lap.
The first owner reached back, thanked him, and took a paper tray. Phil passed the next along. The dogs began sitting up as the smell moved through the rows.
I have never seen such sudden civic cooperation.
A dog farther down gave one bark. Phil glanced toward it, then handed another tray across.
“Let that cool first,” he said.
The owner nodded.
By the time the box reached the end of his row and came back, Phil had helped feed the very zoo he’d objected to.
Lonnie gave Ray and me our chili dogs separately. Ray held his at shoulder height as he stepped down beside us.
“Improved security,” he said.
Mine stayed in my lap, behind my elbow. Marriage had taught me several things; Tater had taught me practical food defense.
Phil leaned forward with the last plain hot dog.
“This one his?”
“Yes.”
He held it toward me rather than toward Tater.
Tater looked up. His eyebrows did their work.
Phil’s mouth moved a little.
“He’s got quite a face.”
“He practices.”
I took the tray. Phil settled back, and neither of us had to make a ceremony of it.
I broke off a small piece, let it cool, and held it in my closed hand.
“Wait.”
Tater waited.
I opened my fingers.
“Gently.”
He took it with his lips, barely touching my skin.
Behind us, Phil said nothing.
Ray finished his replacement dinner standing beside row 9. Every bite reached its intended destination. Marcy ate nothing, but she looked deeply pleased with the distribution system she had invented out of a baseball cap.
When his radio stirred, Ray checked it and stepped away from the seats.
“I need to get back.”
“Thank you,” I said.
He gave Tater one last rub.
“Keep your nose out of trouble.”
Tater licked his wrist.
“I wouldn’t take that as a promise,” I said.
Ray grinned and went up the steps.
I put the remaining pieces of Tater’s hot dog away for later. He inspected my empty fingers, then lay down with his body tucked beside my seat and his chin across my shoe.
The game continued. I couldn’t have told you what happened during most of that inning. I was busy coming back into my own skin.
Marcy turned around.
“You coming to the next dog night?”
“I think so.”
“Good. Sit near us.”
I said I would.
No excuse about work came out. No vague promise to check my calendar. I opened my phone and made a note to look for the next date.
Then I put it away.
Behind me, Phil adjusted his seat cushion and asked the man beside him about the count. Ahead of me, Marcy put her cap back on. The boy with the glove leaned toward Tater, asked permission, and gave his ear a careful rub.
I ate the last bite of my chili dog.
Tater lifted his head hopefully.
“No,” I said. “You’ve retired from that work.”
He put his chin back on my sneaker.
I stayed through the last out. When the rows began to empty, I waited for space instead of rushing to get ahead of anyone. Then I gathered the rubbish, slung my bag over my shoulder, and stood.
“Ready, sweetheart?”
Tater rose beside me. We took the steps together, and at the top I stopped to let him look back toward the field.
His tail brushed my leg.
“Yes,” I said, scratching the notch in his ear. “We can come again.”
For another dog story with a surprising turn, check out the stray who brought an old man to Kennel Nine. And if you’re in the mood for family drama, there’s a wedding reunion with an ex and a father’s last-minute college ultimatum.




