Corey’s spelling bee ribbon lay on the hallway floor where he’d dropped it, one corner folded under. My brother kept watching television.
We’d come home last Thursday at 4:15 to an open backyard gate and an empty leash hook. Jerry, who’d stayed home claiming a headache, had taken Biscuit to the county shelter. He’d signed as the owner. Ten minutes, he said.
Then he finally looked at me.
“He’s not really yours, Renee, and neither is that mutt.”
Corey dropped his ribbon. By the time I reached his bedroom, he was putting shirts into the pillowcase he’d brought to me at seven, after four homes.
“If he can go back, I can go back,” he said.
I told Jerry to pack, took the pillowcase from Corey, and promised we were bringing Biscuit home.
That dog had joined us six months after Corey did. At the shelter in Muncie, my boy passed forty kennels before a shaggy brown dog pushed his nose into his palm. One ear up, one down. Sixty-five dollars later, we owned a dog named for diner biscuits. For two years, he’d slept at Corey’s feet.
Jerry had complained about shedding and barking since moving in that September. Losing his apartment apparently entitled him to opinions about everyone else’s place in mine.
We left at 4:40, Corey holding the water bowl. Three weeks of spelling practice with Biscuit, four rounds, one missing h in “rhythm,” and now this.
At 5:06, twenty-four minutes before closing, Dominique at the shelter desk told us someone had paid a deposit about an hour earlier.
I showed her my adoption form and Corey’s drawing, saved together on my phone.
She fetched the man.
He looked about eighty, in a tan jacket and cap. Biscuit nearly pulled him over reaching Corey. Then the man said he’d searched for this dog for three years.
He called him Sergeant.
Biscuit sat beside his left boot.
“His name isn’t Biscuit,” the man said. “It’s Sergeant. And he was my son’s.”
The Hand Around the Leash
Corey pulled the water bowl against his chest. Its rim pressed a line into his chin.
I put my hand on his shoulder.
“Please don’t make him wait,” I said.
The man lowered himself onto the bench beside the desk. Biscuit stayed at his boot, looking up, and Corey looked at me as though I’d promised him something I couldn’t deliver.
The man held the loop of the leash toward him.
“Take this first.”
Corey didn’t move.
“Go on. I should have handed it over when you came through that door.”
I took it and laid it in Corey’s palm. His fingers closed around it so hard his knuckles went pale.
“My name’s Walter,” the man said. “And I said that wrong. He’s called Biscuit now. I can hear that.”
Dominique brought a chair for Corey. He stayed on the floor.
“Your son?” I said.
“He’s alive. His name’s Alan.”
Walter rubbed his knee through his trousers.
“He had a stroke three years ago. Couldn’t go home afterward. While we were moving his things out, the dog got loose. Somebody left a door open. I was there. Might have been me.”
His hand stopped on his knee.
“We searched. Put up pictures. Called shelters. I don’t know where he spent all that time before he landed here.”
Dominique sat behind the desk without reaching for her keyboard.
“Alan lives where people can help him now,” Walter said. “He doesn’t get many words out. But when I bring photographs, he points to the one with the dog. Every time.”
Corey loosened his grip on the bowl.
“He asks about him?”
“Every time.”
Biscuit put his chin on Walter’s knee. Walter covered the dog’s head with his hand, and for a moment nobody tried to get anything done.
I had come ready to fight an old man for a dog. I wasn’t proud of it, but I’d been prepared to use my handbag if necessary. Now I wanted someone to bring him a glass of water.
“I come through here when I can,” Walter said. “Today I saw him. Didn’t trust my own eyes. That’s why I stayed back there.”
He looked at Corey.
“I wanted you to know he wasn’t thrown away because he was bad. Somebody loved him before you. Somebody’s been missing him.”
Corey’s mouth trembled.
“Then you need him.”
Walter bent forward.
“I needed to find him. That’s different.”
“But your son—”
“Needs to know he’s safe.”
Corey pulled Biscuit closer. The dog went without hesitation, settling sideways against his legs with the graceless collapse he used on my clean laundry.
“Could he still see him?” Corey said.
I pressed his shoulder gently.
“You don’t have to decide anything right now, baby.”
“I mean see him. Not keep him.”
Walter took off his cap. His hair stood up where the band had been.
“If your mother says it’s all right.”
“We can talk about a visit,” I said. “After we’re home.”
Walter nodded, then looked away. His eyes had filled, and he seemed determined to handle that privately in a room with absolutely nowhere private to look.
Dominique turned the screen toward me.
“Your original record matches the dog and your identification. Your brother represented himself as the owner. I’m recording that you dispute and did not authorize the surrender.”
“I don’t dispute it,” I said. “He lied.”
She met my eyes.
“I’ll put that in your statement.”
Walter asked her to cancel his hold. She started his deposit refund while I signed the statement and the release acknowledging that Biscuit was leaving with me.
There was no second adoption fee. I didn’t have to buy my son’s dog twice.
Corey finally put the bowl down.
“Could he have water?”
Dominique took it to fill it. Such an ordinary request. I nearly cried over the plumbing.
Walter drew his phone from his jacket and opened a photograph. He held it where Corey could see without letting go of Biscuit.
A younger man sat on a porch step with a brown dog across his shoes. The ears were unmistakable.
Corey studied it.
“He still sits on shoes.”
“Alan used to complain he couldn’t get out the door.”
“He doesn’t mean it,” Corey said. “He just wants to come.”
Walter swallowed.
“I expect you’re right.”
We exchanged phone numbers. I wrote Walter’s name into my phone myself because my fingers needed a job that wasn’t shaking.
Then Jerry’s name lit the screen.
I let it ring.
A message followed.
You made your point. Come home and stop this.
I turned the phone facedown.
Corey had read it anyway.
“Is he still there?”
“Apparently.”
His hand went back around the bowl.
Walter started to stand, but I held out a hand, asking for another moment. I crouched beside Corey.
“You can wait here with me until you’re ready. We can go home together. You don’t have to speak to Jerry.”
“Will he take him again?”
“No.”
“How do you know?”
That was a fair question. A terrible one to have to earn.
I picked up my phone and called my brother.
Jerry’s Key
Jerry answered before the second ring.
“Are you done?”
Dominique stopped typing. Walter stayed on the bench. Corey leaned into Biscuit with the leash wound through his fingers.
“You’re on speaker,” I said. “I’m at the shelter with Corey, Dominique, and the man who placed the hold.”
“Why would you put me on speaker?”
“Tell Dominique whose dog you surrendered.”
“Oh, for God’s sake. You got him, then? Great. Bring him home. We can discuss this like adults.”
“Whose dog?”
“You know what I meant when I signed it.”
Dominique moved closer to the phone.
“Jerry, you told us you owned him and could surrender him.”
“I live in the house.”
“That wasn’t what I asked.”
He went quiet.
I kept my eyes on Corey. He was listening with his whole body, even his feet still.
Jerry started again.
“I’ve put up with that animal for months. Hair everywhere. Barking when I’m trying to sleep. She won’t do anything about it. You people take dogs. I brought you a dog.”
“My dog,” Corey said.
Jerry heard him.
“Corey, this is between me and your mother.”
There it was. Your mother. He could find the relationship perfectly well when he wanted the child out of the conversation.
I moved the phone nearer.
“He gets to speak.”
Jerry let out a breath.
“Fine. Your dog. I’m sorry you’re upset. I didn’t think she’d turn it into this.”
Corey looked down.
I wanted to tell Jerry exactly where he could put that apology. Dominique had a jar of dog treats on her desk, and for one wild second I considered billing him for every one.
Instead, I said, “Pack your things. We’ll be home shortly.”
“You can’t seriously mean that.”
“I do.”
“Renee, I’ve got nowhere arranged. I thought you’d cool off. I haven’t packed anything.”
“Then start.”
“You’d throw out your own brother?”
Corey lifted his head.
I didn’t look away from him.
“Yes.”
Jerry started talking over me, about September, about family, about all the times he’d helped me carry something or fix something. Apparently moving a bookcase gave a man permanent voting rights over a child.
Walter stood up.
“May I say something?”
I nodded.
Jerry heard him introduce himself.
“I was the man who wanted the dog. I spent three years hoping he was in a good home. Today I found out he was. Then I found out you took him out of it.”
“You don’t know anything about my family.”
“I know the boy brought his water bowl.”
Jerry had no answer to that.
I ended the call before he could invent one.
Dominique handed me our copy of the release. Walter put his cap back on, and Corey stood, keeping Biscuit close to his knee.
Outside, Walter stopped beside us while I opened the car.
“Would you like me to follow you?” he said. “I can wait out front.”
I nearly said we were fine. Women will say they’re fine while standing in a crater holding a handbag.
“Yes,” I said. “Thank you.”
Corey buckled himself in. Biscuit climbed onto the seat beside him, and I set the empty bowl on the floor.
We left with Walter following in his car.
At home, Jerry had managed to put one bag near the couch. The television was still on.
I opened the front door and held it while Corey and Biscuit went inside. Walter stayed on the porch, where I’d asked him to wait.
Jerry got up.
“Oh, you brought an audience.”
“I brought the dog home.”
He looked toward Corey.
“See? He’s fine. No harm done.”
Corey put the bowl on its mat by the kitchen doorway.
Then he turned around.
“I packed my shirts.”
Jerry frowned.
“What?”
“In my pillowcase.”
I set my keys down.
“He thought he was next.”
“That’s ridiculous. I never said that.”
“You said I wasn’t hers,” Corey said.
Jerry rubbed both hands over his face.
“Kids take everything literally. Renee, help me out here.”
“No.”
“I was angry. I said something. People say things.”
Corey bent to pick up his ribbon. It was still where he’d dropped it.
Jerry reached toward him.
“Come on, buddy.”
Corey stepped behind me.
I held up my hand.
“Don’t.”
Jerry’s face changed then. He looked past me toward Walter, then back at the child who’d once brought him the television remote so he wouldn’t have to get up.
“I didn’t know you were going to pack,” he said.
Corey pressed the ribbon flat against his shirt.
Jerry looked at me.
“I’ll tell the shelter I shouldn’t have signed. I’ll pay whatever it cost. Just don’t do this in front of him.”
“You did.”
He stood there for a moment. Then he went to the guest room.
Drawers opened. Hangers scraped. I stayed in the hallway with Corey beside me, and neither of us offered to help.
When Jerry returned with the rest of his things, he held out his key.
I took it.
“I said I was sorry,” he said.
“You still have to leave.”
The Bowl on Its Mat
Jerry carried his bags through the doorway. Walter stepped aside without offering him a hand.
My brother stopped on the porch.
“Where am I supposed to sleep tonight?”
“You’ll have to arrange that.”
“I could stay one more night. Keep the door shut. I won’t go near either of them.”
Corey’s hand slipped into the back pocket of my jeans. He used to do that in grocery stores when he thought we might get separated.
“No,” I said.
Jerry looked down at the key in my hand, as though that little piece of metal might argue his case better.
“I’ll call you tomorrow.”
“I’m not discussing it tomorrow.”
He picked up the bag he’d set down and went to his car.
I stayed at the open door until he drove away. He lost the guest room that evening, the meals I cooked, the laundry I did without thinking, and the freedom to walk into my house. None of it required a speech. He took his bags. I kept the key.
Walter waited until I turned toward him.
“Would you like me to stay another minute?”
I asked Corey.
He nodded.
So Walter came inside and sat on the edge of the couch. I turned off the television. The silence afterward felt like taking off shoes that had hurt all day.
Biscuit went straight to the kitchen doorway and nosed his bowl.
“Right,” I said. “Management has a complaint.”
Corey carried it to the sink. I helped him fill it, then he put it back on the mat and stood over Biscuit while he drank.
Walter kept his hands on his knees. He wasn’t reaching for the dog now. He was letting our house belong to us.
Corey went to him with the ribbon.
“I didn’t win.”
Walter held out his hand to see it.
“Did you get up there?”
“Yes.”
“That’s more than I’d have done at nine.”
“I left the h out.”
“Which word?”
“Rhythm.”
Walter considered that.
“Seems a word could spare one letter with two of the same in it.”
Corey gave a small laugh. It escaped before he could stop it.
I sat down on the chair opposite them. My legs had finally discovered we’d been using them.
Walter asked whether he might take a photograph for Alan.
I looked at Corey first.
“With Biscuit?”
“If you’d like.”
Corey sat on the rug. Biscuit leaned against him, wet chin and all, and Walter took the picture. Then Corey held up his ribbon for another one.
“Can you tell him Biscuit helped me practice?”
“I will.”
“And he sleeps on my bed.”
“I’ll tell him that too.”
Walter put the phone away carefully.
We agreed he could call me Saturday afternoon about arranging a visit. There would be no surprise visits, no taking Biscuit anywhere without us. Walter nodded before I’d finished.
At the door, Corey reached for his sleeve.
“You can call him Sergeant when we visit.”
Walter bent his head.
“Thank you.”
“But I’m going to call him Biscuit.”
“I think he’ll manage.”
After Walter left, I closed the door and slid the bolt. Corey stood behind me, listening to the click.
Then he held out the ribbon.
“Can you fix the corner?”
I smoothed it between my fingers. It would keep a crease, but it was still blue and still his.
“We can put it under a book tonight.”
He nodded and started toward his bedroom.
I followed him.
The pillowcase sat on the bed where I’d left it. Shirts bulged against its sides. One sleeve hung over the opening, and Corey went to tuck it inside.
He stopped with the sleeve in his hand.
“Do I unpack?”
I sat on the mattress.
“Yes, baby.”
He pulled out a shirt. I folded it, and he carried it to the drawer.
We did the next one the same way.
I wanted to promise that nothing would ever frighten him again. I wanted to get the whole day out of his head and replace it with his fourth-round spelling word, his ribbon, the joke he’d made on the ride home.
All I could do was fold the shirts he’d packed because a grown man had been cruel.
“I should have made Jerry leave when he first talked about you that way,” I said.
Corey shut the drawer.
“You told him to stop.”
“I did. And when he didn’t, I should have done more.”
He came back to the bed.
“Was it hard?”
“Making him leave?”
He nodded.
“Yes.”
“Because he’s your brother?”
“Yes.”
He stood there, thinking. I let him.
Then he climbed onto the bed beside me and put his forehead against my arm.
I held him until Biscuit decided there was room for three and shoved his nose between us.
Later, after teeth and pajamas and one last trip outside, I spread the pillowcase over Corey’s pillow. He climbed beneath the covers while Biscuit made his usual inconvenient circle at the foot of the bed.
The ribbon lay under a book on the dresser.
I reached for the lamp.
“Mom?”
I left it on.
“Do you think Biscuit missed being Sergeant?”
“Maybe sometimes.”
“Can he like both?”
“I think he showed us he can.”
Corey stretched out his foot beneath the blanket until it touched the dog.
Biscuit thumped his tail.
“R-h-y-t-h-m,” Corey said.
The tail thumped again.
Corey pulled the blanket over Biscuit’s paws.
For more family drama and tender moments involving kids, read about the day an ex-husband cornered a mother at the children’s hospital and the surprising visit to a clinic with twin boys. You can also follow a young boy’s story in his homemade uniform.




