A Mother Asked Me to Move My Son Out of the Picture

My son practiced his smile in the dark screen of my phone before we left for the park.

“Too many teeth?” he said.

“Show every one you’ve got. We paid good money for those.”

Ben laughed and handed it back. He was seven, with a loose tooth he refused to surrender and a rare cranio-facial condition that strangers often thought entitled them to stare.

His life had included operations, therapy appointments, and enough hospital stays to make birthdays seem scarce. He could tell you which adhesive hurt least coming off. He also believed putting underpants on a teddy bear was the highest form of comedy.

People tended to see only one of those things.

When he was barely two, a mother at our grocery store pulled her child away from him. Her name was Carla. We lived in the same neighborhood, although that afternoon she behaved as though we occupied different planets.

I held Ben against me and kissed his hair. I told myself she didn’t understand.

That explanation got a workout over the years.

At playgrounds, adults stared while their children waited for permission to approach him. In waiting rooms, people looked away too late. Under photographs I posted, strangers used words like “creepy” and “monster,” then went back to whatever decent people apparently did between hurting children.

I deleted those comments before he could read them.

On that Saturday, we were going to the neighborhood park for a group photograph. Ben wore the yellow shirt he’d picked himself. He’d been promised a place beside his friend, Miles.

He checked his reflection once more before we walked out.

People could spend a full minute looking at my child and never see that grin. They missed the joy he offered them before they had offered him anything.

The Space Beside Miles

At the park, Miles ran toward us carrying a ball beneath his shirt.

“I’m having a baby,” he said.

“It’s a football,” Ben said. “You should see somebody.”

They collapsed against each other laughing. I stood with Ben’s water bottle and tried to remember whether I’d ever been that easily pleased.

There were twelve children in the photograph and six adults helping arrange them. Ruth, the neighbor taking the picture, had brought a little bench for the front row. She moved it twice while everyone offered advice worth approximately what she’d charged us.

Nothing.

Carla stood beside the bench, straightening her daughter Sophie’s collar. She lifted a hand when she saw me. We exchanged the sort of greeting women can maintain for years without ever exchanging trust.

I hadn’t forgotten the grocery store. She’d never mentioned it.

Ben and Miles joined the children near the bench. Miles put his arm around Ben’s shoulders, then removed it so they could argue about who was taller.

Ruth raised her camera.

“Can everybody see me?”

Carla stepped in front of her.

“Just a second. I think we need to rearrange.”

She moved Sophie toward the middle. Then she put two children behind the bench. Ben waited, hands at his sides, accepting instructions as readily as he did when a nurse needed his arm.

Carla looked toward me.

“Would you mind having Ben stand with you for this one?”

I held out his water bottle, thinking she meant he needed a drink.

“Why?”

“We’re doing the neighborhood picture first.”

“He lives in the neighborhood.”

“Of course he does.”

She smiled at Ruth, asking for help without quite asking.

“We can do a separate one afterward. Something special for him.”

Ben stepped away from Miles.

That was the part that hurt first. Before I had answered, before anyone had agreed, he started making it easier for her.

I put the bottle on the grass.

“Stay where you are, sweetheart.”

Carla came closer. She lowered her voice, but Ben was only a few feet away.

“Some of the younger children might be uncomfortable.”

Sophie leaned around her mother.

“I’m not.”

Carla touched her shoulder.

“Let the grown-ups talk.”

Miles reached for Ben’s sleeve. Ben didn’t take his place again. He stood between the group and me, with nowhere apparently correct to put his feet.

I wanted to lift him up and leave. At seven he was getting heavy, but I would have carried him all the way home. I could picture our front door closing, the yellow shirt in the laundry, another place quietly crossed off our list.

Instead, I asked Carla which child had complained.

She folded her arms.

“I didn’t say anyone complained.”

“Then ask them.”

“Oh, please. There’s no reason to turn this into a discussion in front of everybody.”

Behind her, Ruth lowered the camera.

“It already is one,” she said.

Carla looked at the children, then back at me.

“This picture goes on the neighborhood noticeboard. People keep it. I’m trying to make sure we have something everyone is happy with.”

I looked at my son.

He was rubbing the bottom of his shirt between his fingers. He did that before procedures, when someone was being pleasant while arranging something he wasn’t going to like.

“Ben,” I said, “come here a minute.”

He came immediately.

I crouched, and my knee made the sort of noise that ought to come with a repair estimate.

“Do you want to be in the picture?”

He looked over my shoulder toward the path.

“We can go.”

“I know we can. I’m asking what you want.”

His mouth tightened.

“I told Miles I’d stand by him.”

“Then that’s what we’ll do.”

He put a hand on my shoulder.

“Are you going to cry?”

I nearly did then. There should be a rule against a child asking that while you’re doing your best not to.

“Maybe later. Right now I’m going to get grass stains on my trousers.”

He glanced at my knee.

“You already did.”

“Excellent. One job finished.”

His smile came back for a second. Then he leaned close to my ear.

“Should I keep my mouth shut in this one?”

For a moment I couldn’t get enough air to answer.

“No, baby.”

“It looks less different when I do.”

I put both hands around his.

“Your smile belongs in the picture.”

He studied my face, checking whether I meant it or was just doing the mother thing where we announce that a burnt biscuit is delicious.

I stood and held out my hand.

Carla let out a breath.

“Can we please just take the photograph?”

“Yes,” I said. “With all twelve children.”

She reached toward Ben as if to guide him to the far end.

I stepped between them.

“Beside Miles. Where he was.”

The Yellow Shirt

Carla dropped her hand.

“I was trying to be considerate,” she said. “You must know people sometimes react. It’s better to handle it quietly than put him through something embarrassing.”

Ben’s fingers tightened around mine.

I could have told her about his last operation. I could have described the night he woke frightened and still remembered to ask whether I had a blanket. I had those stories ready because I’d spent years offering proof that my son deserved ordinary kindness.

But the other eleven children hadn’t been asked to submit references.

“He came for a photograph,” I said.

“And he’ll have one. I offered that.”

“With his friends.”

Carla looked at Ruth.

“You understand what I’m saying.”

Ruth put the lens cap in her pocket.

“I understand that you’ve stopped a picture because you don’t want Ben in it.”

“That is an awful way to put it.”

“Tell me a better way.”

Carla’s face reddened. Sophie moved away from her and stood beside Miles.

I kept expecting another adult to step in, perhaps with a joke that would let everyone pretend we’d only disagreed about the arrangement. One of the other parents bent to retie a shoe that didn’t need tying.

I knew that escape route. I’d used it myself. A little laugh, a change of subject, home before the tears.

Ben released my hand.

“Can I sit down?”

The bench was a few steps away. I nodded.

He sat at the end, leaving room for the others. Miles sat next to him. Sophie joined them without looking at her mother.

Carla pointed toward the bench.

“There. That’s fine. Let’s leave it.”

But Ben folded his lips inward.

The children were settling back into place, and my son was arranging his face so that an adult would approve of it.

I lifted a hand toward Ruth.

“Wait.”

Carla made a noise in her throat.

“What now?”

I went to Ben. I didn’t touch his mouth or tell him to smile. He’d had enough hands arranging him for one morning.

“Would you like a minute?”

He nodded.

We walked to the other side of the bench, still close enough for everyone to hear. I wanted him to know we weren’t being sent away.

“Did somebody ask you not to smile?” I said.

He shook his head.

“Then where did that idea come from?”

He looked at Carla.

She began speaking before I could.

“I never said that. I absolutely never said anything about his smile.”

“I didn’t say you did.”

“I won’t have words put in my mouth.”

Ben tucked himself against my side.

“I just thought it would help.”

Ruth turned away and wiped beneath one eye with her thumb.

I kept my hand on Ben’s back.

“You don’t have to help with this.”

He looked up.

“But everybody’s waiting.”

There it was. He was worried about inconveniencing the people who’d stood there while someone tried to remove him.

I kissed the top of his head, just as I’d done in the grocery store. This time I didn’t use the kiss to end the conversation.

“Carla,” I said, “he heard you.”

She looked toward the path.

“I can see you’re upset.”

“He heard you say the picture would be better without him.”

“That isn’t what I meant.”

“Then tell him what you meant.”

She stared at me.

“You’re asking me to have an adult conversation with a child.”

“I’m asking you to speak to the child you spoke about.”

For several seconds, the only sound was Miles bouncing his heel against the bench.

Carla had been comfortable speaking around Ben. With him looking directly at her, she seemed to run out of places to put her eyes.

At last she bent slightly.

“Ben, I’m sorry if your feelings were hurt.”

He nodded. That quick, obedient nod again.

I almost accepted it. My body was desperate to finish. My palms were wet, my son was tired, and I wanted nothing more demanding than getting us both home.

Then Sophie spoke.

“Mom, you told him to leave.”

Carla straightened.

“Sophie.”

“You did.”

“I said we’d take another picture.”

“But he was already in this one.”

Sophie wasn’t shouting. She sounded confused, as though her mother was refusing to admit where the bench stood.

Carla looked at me with tears in her eyes.

“Are you happy now?”

I wanted to say several things that would have required explaining to the children afterward.

“No.”

Ruth stepped beside us.

“I’m going to finish the picture,” she said. “You can stand back with the rest of the parents.”

“I organized this.”

“You invited people. I agreed to photograph all their children.”

Carla reached for Sophie’s hand.

“We’re going.”

Sophie stayed beside the bench.

“I want my picture with my friends.”

Carla’s hand remained out for a moment. Then she lowered it.

Ben pulled gently at my sleeve.

“Can we do it now?”

I looked at Ruth. She nodded and raised her camera.

Carla stepped backward, out of the place from which she’d been directing everyone.

For once, my son didn’t have to move.

Every Tooth

Ben sat between Miles and Sophie. The other children found their places around them, and Ruth crouched in front of the bench.

I stood behind her, still holding the water bottle I’d retrieved from the grass.

“All right,” she said. “Everybody look here.”

Ben pressed his lips together.

I didn’t call out. A smile demanded for my comfort would be one more thing he’d have to produce for a grown-up.

Miles leaned toward him and said something I couldn’t hear.

Ben’s shoulders moved.

Miles said it again.

Then Ben laughed, mouth open, head tipped toward his friend. Ruth took the photograph.

“What did you say?” Sophie said.

Miles puffed out his shirt.

“The baby’s kicking.”

All three of them broke up. Ruth kept taking pictures, and the children around them began laughing without knowing why.

I laughed too. Then I cried, which was inconvenient because I’d brought water, sunscreen, and a packet of crackers, but apparently had prepared for every emergency except my own face.

One of the other parents handed me a tissue.

“I’m sorry I didn’t say anything,” she said.

I took it.

“Next time, please do.”

She nodded and stayed beside me until Ruth finished.

The children scattered toward the grass. Ben stopped long enough to ask whether he could play ball with Miles and Sophie.

“Yes.”

“You’re sure?”

“Go. Before Miles gives birth again.”

He ran.

Carla remained near the bench. Her daughter was laughing with my son, and there was no one left for Carla to rearrange.

She came toward me.

“I need you to understand that I wasn’t trying to hurt him.”

I folded the tissue into my palm.

“You kept going after he stepped out.”

Her mouth opened, then closed.

“I thought you were making it bigger than it needed to be.”

“He was trying not to smile.”

She looked toward the children.

Ben missed a pass and chased the ball past Sophie. His yellow shirt lifted at the back as he ran. Carla watched him retrieve it.

“I didn’t know he’d think that.”

“I didn’t either.”

That stopped her more effectively than anything else I’d said.

Ruth came over with the camera and held it where we could see. There were all twelve children. Ben leaned toward Miles, laughing, one hand braced against the bench.

Carla looked at the little screen.

Ruth turned to me.

“Are you comfortable with this being printed for the noticeboard? I’ll ask the other parents too.”

“Ask Ben,” I said.

She nodded.

Carla rubbed her hands together.

“I can pay for the prints.”

I shook my head.

“This doesn’t need a donation.”

“I don’t know what you want me to do.”

“Apologize without asking him to make you feel better.”

She stood still for a moment, then walked toward the grass.

I followed far enough to hear. Ruth stayed beside me.

Carla waited until the children stopped playing. She crouched in front of Ben, with Sophie and Miles standing nearby.

“I asked your mom to take you out of the picture because of how you look,” she said.

The words were ugly. They were also, at last, the words she’d been avoiding.

“That was wrong. You belong with your friends, and I’m sorry.”

Ben held the ball against his stomach.

“Okay.”

She nodded, but didn’t reach for a hug or ask whether they were friends now.

“May I speak to Sophie a minute?”

Ben handed Sophie the ball.

“We’ll wait.”

I had to look down at the grass.

Carla took her daughter aside. I couldn’t hear their conversation, and it wasn’t mine to have. Sophie returned to the game. Carla went to the other parents near the bench, and this time she didn’t lower her voice.

“I was the one who held up the photograph,” she said. “I asked for Ben to be left out. I’m sorry you all had to hear that.”

Ruth stood beside me with the camera against her chest.

“I’ll handle the picture from here,” she said.

Carla nodded.

Before she left, she stopped beside me.

“I hope you’ll give me another chance.”

“Don’t ask him to be smaller again.”

She looked at me.

“I won’t.”

“Good.”

I went to get my son.

Ruth showed Ben the photograph before we left the park. He leaned close to the screen, studying himself between his friends.

“Can that be the one on the board?” she said.

“Yes,” he said. “Can we have one too?”

She promised him a print.

At home that afternoon, he kicked off his shoes in the hall and reached for my phone.

For a second I dreaded the dark screen. I couldn’t bear to see him checking which version of his face might be safest to take outside.

But he opened the camera.

“Come here.”

I sat beside him on the bottom stair. There was grass on my trousers and a cracker crumb stuck to his shirt. He held the phone too close, giving me a forehead large enough to rent out.

“Further away,” I said.

“My arm only goes this far.”

“Fair criticism.”

He leaned against me and turned the phone sideways. On the screen, his cheek pressed into mine.

“Do your real smile, Mom.”

I did.

He studied us for a moment, then grinned wide enough to show the loose tooth.

“All the teeth,” he said, and took our picture.

For more stories about moments that make people stop and look twice, read the movie records that needed a second look and the deer with a surprising discovery. And for another unsettling story involving children, see what Jenna left the kids facing.