Hello there! Let’s take a journey back in time to the 90s, when daytime talk shows ruled the television airwaves. These shows were a mixed bag, offering a daily dose of entertainment, laughter, and shocking revelations. But looking back, we can see that many of the topics that were once normalized were actually not okay at all. Today, we’ll explore some of the exploitative themes that dominated 90s daytime talk shows and reflect on how our sensibilities have changed.

The Exploitative Topics of 90s Daytime Talk Shows

Step right up to the world of shock and exploitation! While discussing important issues like race and offering makeovers can be meaningful, some channels took things too far. It was almost like stepping into a 1800s circus freak show, where guests were ridiculed and treated as mere attractions rather than human beings with feelings. Even in modern reality shows, this unfortunate trend still persists. However, with the benefit of hindsight, we can now recognize the flaws in these older shows and acknowledge the changes in our society’s values.

Let’s take a closer look at some examples. Remember the Satanic Panic in the 80s and 90s? TV channels and daytime talk shows used this cultural hysteria to create fear among parents, convincing them that their goth-looking, Metallica-listening teens needed immediate spiritual intervention. Shows like Maury’s “Please Make Over My Freaky Teen” and the Jenny Jones Show’s “Hey Punk, Lose the Funk!” capitalized on this panic.

These episodes often brought children onto the show, exposing them to mockery and jeering from the crowd. Some segments revolved around girls whose clothes were deemed too provocative or not feminine enough, resulting in makeovers to conform to mainstream beauty standards. While the parents may have approved of the makeovers, many of these teens felt uncomfortable in their new looks.

Boot Camps and Shock Value

Now, let’s turn our attention to another shocking aspect of 90s daytime talk shows: boot camps. The Maury Show featured a segment where parents would bring their troubled teens who had engaged in behaviors like drug use, stealing, or breaking curfew multiple times. These teens were then sent to boot camps like the Reality Adjustment Program (RAP), which was even featured on the show.

However, RAP faced controversy when reports of verbal abuse by prison guards emerged. In a two-hour program, the teens were often locked in cells in the Lancaster County Prison and told to adapt to their surroundings if they wanted to change. Many criticized the program for taking place in a prison filled with adult criminals and questioned its effectiveness.

Teenage girls also found themselves sent to boot camps for daring to have sex. Daytime talk shows often had episodes where desperate mothers brought their “out-of-control” girls, with so-called experts advising therapy or boot camps as a solution. Occasionally, the hosts would claim that bringing their children onto the show was proof of the parents’ love for them.

Of course, no discussion about shocking TV shows would be complete without mentioning the late Jerry Springer. Known for exploiting and perpetuating harmful stereotypes about poor, Black, and transgender individuals, his show faced heavy criticism. Segments would range from Ku Klux Klan members confronting Black individuals on stage to guests physically fighting over romantic partners. Transgender individuals revealing their identity often faced audience disgust. The show relied on these hot social topics for shock value and entertainment.

The Death of Scott Amedure

Sadly, the exploitative nature of 90s daytime TV shows had dire consequences. One particularly tragic case involved the Jenny Jones Show in 1995. During a segment, Scott Amedure, a 32-year-old man, revealed his crush on his acquaintance Jonathan Schmitz, stating that he was gay. Schmitz initially seemed embarrassed but politely responded that he was straight.

Unbeknownst to the public, Schmitz found a note from Amedure on his door three days after the filming. In a fit of rage and humiliation, he went to Amedure’s home and fatally shot him. Schmitz later turned himself in to the police. In 1996, he was found guilty of murder. A civil jury in 1999 held the producers of the Jenny Jones Show liable for the death and ordered them to pay $25 million to Amedure’s family. However, this ruling was later reversed on appeal. Schmitz was released from prison in 2017.

The tragic incident involving Scott Amedure raises some important questions about the boundaries of reality entertainment. How far is too far? What measures are in place to protect those who participate in reality shows? While reality TV has evolved since the 90s, participants are still vulnerable to exploitation.

For instance, shows like Netflix’s Love is Blind have faced criticism for subjects enduring limited food, water supplies, restricted outdoor access, and sleep deprivation. Several individuals who appeared on Love Island have experienced significant mental distress, which has even led to tragic suicides. Clearly, although reality TV has changed, there is still much work to be done to ensure the well-being and safety of participants.

While daytime talk shows in the 90s provided endless entertainment, it is essential to reflect on the exploitative nature of some of their topics. What may have seemed normal then should now be acknowledged as problematic. As we move forward, it is crucial to prioritize the well-being of individuals on reality TV, set ethical boundaries, and foster a more compassionate and understanding entertainment industry.

Share on Facebook