I came home from work on a Tuesday to find my fence in a pile of lumber on my front lawn – and a notice from the HOA president stapled to my mailbox saying I was in VIOLATION of neighborhood guidelines.
I’m Tammy. Forty-four, divorced, raising my daughter Brooke alone in a subdivision outside of Raleigh.
We’d lived on Pinecrest Lane for six years. It was quiet. The neighbors were fine. I kept my yard neat, paid my dues on time, never caused a single problem.
The fence had been there since I bought the house. White cedar, four feet tall, right along the property line. Brooke used to hang her little wind chimes on it.
Then Debra Sizemore became HOA president.
Within a month she was sending violations to half the street. Wrong mailbox color. Trash cans visible from the road. A basketball hoop that was two inches too close to the sidewalk.
My fence was “unapproved material and height.”
I sent her the original permit. She rejected it. Said the bylaws had been UPDATED.
I asked to see the updated bylaws. She said they were being “reformatted” and unavailable.
Then one Tuesday, without a hearing, without a vote, she had a crew come tear the whole thing down while I was at work.
Brooke called me crying.
I filed a complaint with the HOA board. Debra WAS the board. She’d appointed her sister and her neighbor’s husband. They dismissed it in forty-eight hours.
So I hired a surveyor.
Not for my fence. For the whole block.
When Dale Mercer came out with his equipment, I walked the property line with him inch by inch. I wasn’t looking for my boundary anymore. I was looking for HERS.
Her in-ground pool – the big one she’d put in last summer, the one she hosted the Fourth of July party around – sat eleven feet past her property line.
On county land.
No permit. No easement. No approval.
I didn’t say a word to Debra. I filed directly with the county code enforcement office and copied the state HOA regulatory board.
Three days later, a county inspector showed up at Debra’s house with a CEASE AND REMEDIATION ORDER.
I watched from my kitchen window. Debra came outside in her bathrobe. She read the paper. Her hands started shaking.
That Friday, I got a call from a lawyer I’d never heard of. He said he was representing Debra Sizemore and asked if we could “resolve this quietly.”
I said no.
Monday morning, a second envelope arrived – this one from the county clerk’s office, marked URGENT. I opened it at the kitchen table and my stomach flipped.
It wasn’t about Debra’s pool.
It was about my house.
Brooke walked in, saw my face, and stopped in the doorway. “Mom,” she said slowly, “what’s wrong?”
Before I could answer, my phone rang. It was Dale the surveyor. His voice was tight. “Tammy, don’t talk to anyone yet. I found something else when I re-ran the plats – and you need to come see this BEFORE Debra does.”
What Dale Found in the Plats
I told Brooke I’d explain later. She didn’t push. She’s sixteen and she reads a room better than most adults I know.
I drove to Dale’s office on Glenwood with the county envelope sitting unopened in my passenger seat. I’d skimmed it enough to see the words encroachment and recorded easement and then I’d stopped reading because my hands were doing something I didn’t like.
Dale’s office is a converted ranch house with survey equipment stacked in what used to be a dining room. He had two plat maps spread across a folding table and a yellow legal pad with numbers on it. He’s maybe sixty, wears the same Carhartt vest every time I’ve seen him, and he does not waste words.
He pointed to a line on the older of the two maps. “This is the original recorded plat from 1987, when Pinecrest was first developed. See this easement here, running along the back third of your lot?”
I saw it.
“It’s a drainage easement. County utility access. Standard stuff. Recorded, legal, never went away.”
“Okay,” I said.
“Now look at the 2003 plat. When the subdivision was replatted after they added the second phase.” He tapped the newer map. “That easement is gone. Just gone. Not vacated, not transferred. Gone.”
I looked at both maps for a long moment. “Someone removed it.”
“Someone redrew it without it. Whether that was a drafting error in 2003 or something else, I can’t tell you.” He paused. “What I can tell you is that the county apparently re-surveyed this corridor last month. Infrastructure project. Storm drain work. And when they ran their records against the original plat, they found the discrepancy.”
The envelope in my bag suddenly made more sense.
“So the county is saying there’s an easement on my property that’s been on record since 1987, it just got dropped from the 2003 version. And they want access.”
“They want to confirm the easement is still valid. Which, legally, it almost certainly is, because the original recording never got vacated.” He took his glasses off and set them on the table. “Here’s the thing, Tammy. Your house has been sitting on this lot for six years. Your fence, the one Debra tore down, was on the property line. Not in the easement. The easement runs along the back.”
“So my fence wasn’t the problem.”
“Your fence was never the problem.”
The Part I Hadn’t Noticed
I sat with that for a second.
Then he said, “Look at where the easement runs.”
He traced it with his finger on the 1987 map. It came in from the back of my lot, ran at a diagonal, and crossed the property line.
Into Debra’s yard.
Not near the pool. The pool was its own disaster. This easement cut right through the northeast corner of her lot, under the decorative stone patio she’d put in three summers ago, and straight through to the street-side drainage infrastructure.
“She built on it,” I said.
“Patio, yes. And those raised garden beds along the back. And that little retaining wall.”
“She built on a drainage easement she didn’t know was there because someone dropped it from the 2003 plat.”
Dale said nothing for a moment. “I can’t speak to what she knew.”
Fair.
I picked up the county envelope and read the whole thing this time. It was a notice of potential easement encroachment affecting four properties on Pinecrest Lane. Mine was one of them. Two others were lots that backed up to the same drainage corridor. And the fourth.
Debra’s.
She’d gotten the same letter.
That was what Dale meant when he said I needed to see this before she did. Not because I’d gotten there first. Because once Debra read her letter and understood what it meant, she was going to start looking for someone to blame. And the person who’d filed the survey request, the person who’d gotten the county sniffing around Pinecrest Lane in the first place?
Me.
Debra Figures It Out
She called me the next morning at seven forty-five.
I was standing in the kitchen in my work clothes eating toast over the sink. Brooke had already left for school.
“You did this,” Debra said. Not a question.
“Good morning, Debra.”
“You hired that surveyor and you sicced the county on my property and now they’re telling me I have to tear out my patio and my garden beds because of some easement that nobody knew existed.”
“I didn’t know about the easement either,” I said. “I got the same letter you did.”
“You started all of this.”
I thought about Brooke calling me crying from the driveway, standing in the lumber pile where her wind chimes used to hang. I thought about forty-eight hours. The dismissal. The sister and the neighbor’s husband, rubber-stamping whatever Debra wanted.
“You tore down my fence,” I said.
Silence.
“Without a hearing. Without a vote. Without giving me a chance to respond.” I put the toast down. “You sent a crew to my house while I was at work.”
“That was a bylaw enforcement action.”
“With bylaws you wouldn’t show me.”
More silence.
“Debra, I didn’t create the easement. The county did, in 1987. I didn’t drop it from the plat either. Someone did that in 2003, and now the county wants to know why.” I paused. “The thing about records is they don’t go away just because someone stops looking at them.”
She hung up.
The HOA Board Gets Complicated
What happened next took about three weeks and involved more certified mail than I’ve sent in my entire life combined.
The state HOA regulatory board had received my original complaint about the bylaw enforcement process. Specifically: the failure to provide documentation of updated bylaws, the absence of a hearing, and the conflict of interest in having the president serve as the sole adjudicating body.
They opened a formal review.
Debra’s lawyer, the one who’d called asking to resolve things quietly, sent me a letter saying that his client was prepared to offer “restitution for the fence materials” if I agreed to withdraw my complaints with both the county and the state board.
I called my own lawyer. Her name is Gail Fischer and she’s been practicing in Wake County for twenty-three years and she laughed, not unkindly, when I read her that letter.
“They want you to give up two active regulatory complaints in exchange for the cost of some cedar boards,” Gail said.
“That’s what it says.”
“Tell them no. In writing. Keep it short.”
I kept it short.
Meanwhile, the county was moving forward with the easement issue entirely separate from anything Debra or I wanted. The 2003 plat discrepancy got referred to the county attorney’s office. The infrastructure project that had started all of this, the storm drain work, was on hold pending resolution of the easement boundaries.
Debra’s patio. Her garden beds. Her retaining wall. All of it was sitting on land that the county had a recorded right to access, and nobody had caught it for twenty years because somebody had quietly left it off a map.
The county wasn’t asking who dropped it. Not yet. But Gail thought they would.
What Brooke Said
One night about two weeks into all of this, Brooke came and sat at the kitchen table while I was going through paperwork.
She looked at the stacks of documents, the survey maps, the certified mail receipts, and she said, “Is this going to be okay?”
I looked up. She’s tall like her dad but she has my eyes and my tendency to go quiet when she’s actually worried.
“Yeah,” I said. “It’s going to be okay.”
“Are we in trouble with the county?”
“No. We got a notice because our property touches the easement corridor. We didn’t build on it. We’re fine.”
She nodded slowly. “Is Debra in trouble?”
I thought about how to answer that. “Debra made some choices,” I finally said. “And now she’s dealing with the results of those choices.”
Brooke looked at the table for a second. “She really just tore down the fence while you were at work.”
“She did.”
“That’s so mean.”
“Yeah.”
Brooke picked up one of the survey maps and studied it with the same look she gets doing geometry homework. “Where are our wind chimes now?”
I hadn’t thought about the wind chimes. I’d been so focused on permits and plats and certified mail that I’d completely forgotten about the five little ceramic wind chimes Brooke had collected over the years and hung on the fence rails.
I went out to the garage and found them in the pile of lumber the crew had left. Three of them were intact. One was cracked. One was gone, probably kicked into the street and run over.
I brought the three good ones inside and set them on the kitchen windowsill.
Where It Stands
The HOA regulatory board completed their review six weeks after I filed. They found that the enforcement action against my fence had violated the association’s own procedural requirements, specifically the requirement for written notice, a cure period, and a hearing before any physical remediation.
Debra was required to reimburse me for the fence. Full replacement cost. White cedar, four feet, same as before.
She also lost the HOA presidency. Not dramatically. No vote, no confrontation. The regulatory board required the association to hold new elections with an independent monitor present. Debra didn’t run.
The county easement issue is still working through their process. The patio and garden beds are still there. I don’t know what Debra’s going to have to do about them or when. That’s between her and the county.
I had the fence rebuilt in October. Brooke came outside when the crew was finishing and walked along it, touching the rails. She went inside and came back with the three wind chimes from the kitchen windowsill.
She hung all three on the same post.
The cracked one too, because she said she liked the sound it made.
—
If this one hit close to home, pass it along to someone who’s been in a fight they didn’t start.
If you’re still reeling from neighborly drama, you might want to check out how another fence fell to a sledgehammer, or read about a three-inch fence that led to a lawsuit. For something a little different, there’s also the fascinating story of a neighbor who found her name painted above a bed.
